Showing posts with label Edgar Degas. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Edgar Degas. Show all posts

Thursday, July 19, 2012

The Bellelli Sisters - Edgar Degas

Edgar Degas, The Bellelli Sisters, 1865-66,
(LACMA)
Edgar Hilaire Germain Degas, one of the most well known and beloved (all those ballerinas...) of Impressionist artists is also one of the most enigmatic.Since it is assumed his ballerinas are lovely and graceful, people seem to not make the connection to the licentious world the artist was actually depicting. But of all of Degas' paintings revealing modernity with all its concurrent problems, it's the family portrait's that I find the most mesmerizing. There is something so disturbing about the discordance and the disconnect that is so palpable in his family portrayals.  The protagonists are usually looking in opposite directions, barely touching with solemn, melancholy expressions.  But this painting with the one girl's face blurred is even more puzzling than most of his other portraits.

Edgar Degas, The Bellelli Family (Family Portrait), 1858-1867
(Musee d'Orsay)

I wrote about the haunting Bellelli Family Portrait last year and it was quite a surprise running into The Bellelli Sisters, during my visit to Los Angeles Country Museum of Art two months ago, as if running into an old friend.  In this portrait Degas' nieces, Giovanna and Guiliana Bellini, are depicted as young ladies as opposed to the little girls in pinafores they are in the family portrait. Degas was very fond of this painting and did not part with it his whole life because he never saw his cousins again after he painted this portrait. If he cared so much for his cousins, and  taking into consideration the closeness he presumably shared with the girls' mother, his aunt Laura, then  this begs the question of why he always chose to represent families in disconnect.  Was it just a part of his artist-journalist persona of reporting his observations of the human condition or was it something else.  The gallery label provides a comprehensive conclusion:
"Edgar Degas's talent for portraiture was manifested in radical compositions and the ability to express the character of his sitters with great subtlety. In this double portrait of his Italian cousins, he gives each figure her own space and direction, suggesting their distinct personalities. Giovanna faces the viewer, while Giulia is turned aside , focused elsewhere. The two sisters are a study in contrast:: one fair, the other dark; one in black, the other in a lighter, brown dress.  Degas blurred the details of Giulia's face, perhaps imitating effects of photography."


Resources:

LACMA gallery label and website 



Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Happy Birthday Mary Cassatt - A True Feminist

Mary Cassatt, A Woman and A Girl Driving, 1881
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)

Mary Cassatt was a maverick among her peers that broke all the conventions of 19th century society while living a perfectly respectable life (which was the most important thing at her day and age) and enjoying success and acceptance as an American Impressionist artist in Paris.   When we are still discussing gender discrimination and social gendered roles, Cassatt managed to work as a professional artist, exhibit with the Impressionists and  leave behind an exceptional legacy for all American artists to follow.  Some might argue at this point that she was born into a privileged background allowing her to pursue her career as an artist in Paris but  I would like to point out that she was from a wealthy family in Philadelphia which was a conservative area with very strict expectations from a woman of her position.  Like all women of her class, she was expected to marry and have children, not go traipsing about in Europe learning to paint and displaying her talents for all the world to see.  

Sunday, May 22, 2011

Edgar Degas - Interior

Edgar Degas, Interior, 1868-1869
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)
I finally got a chance to see one of the most intriguing paintings we studied in Impressionism this semester, at the Philadelphia Museum of Art, Friday evening.  This painting that is all about ambiguity is incredibly fascinating because it can be read as a critique about searching for the narrative in reading and experiencing paintings .  Although it seems to be a painting loaded with meaning, there are no clear clues or answers to any of the questions we typically ask of a painting such as this.

It is the scene of a starkly decorated room that seems to be lacking the personal effects that would be seen in a bedroom of this period inhabited by a gentleman and a partly clad woman.   The room contains a single bed, feminine wallpaper, a dresser with a map hanging over it and a table in the middle with an open sewing box, the silk interior illuminated by the lamp causing our eye to focus on it as the center of attention.  While the gentleman has only removed his hat and placed it on the dresser, the woman is in her undergarments with her corset strewn across the floor by the man.  We know he is of the bourgeois class due to his clothes but have no idea to her social status.  Part of the confusion is due to the mixing up of gender specific objects with their owners.  Typically the woman's clothing would be near her and the clothing or objects relating to the man would be near him reinforcing each gender's identities.  In this painting, Degas has depicted the woman's garments on the bed and the floor near the man while his top hat and the map on the wall (a very male object since they would be the one's who would go exploring the world) are all the way on the other side of the room closer to the woman.

The sewing box would refer to a woman's purity, virginity and doing her duty; in this painting she has set down her sewing which may be a sign of her loosing her virginity, or she could just be a seamstress.  At this time, there was consistent association in poetry and prose between sewing or embroidery and artifice.1 Degas who was famously known for saying 'Art is vice. You don't marry it, you rape it.  Whoever says art says artifice' could be using the sewing box to reinforce this issue.

The single bed, in the room, perfectly made up, might be pointing to this being her room as someone with a position in his employ.  The room itself seems like a domestic interior but it could also be a hotel room because of its impersonal decor. In which case they could be an unmarried couple having an assignation or a couple who is traveling.  The artist has not given us specific enough clues to figure out the relationship between the couple or the relevance of the interior they are standing in.

The dramatic lighting and the use of chiaroscuro as well as the tilted perspective of the room all add to the theatricality of this painting. The visual distortion of spaces and figural proportions in order to achieve a more expressive effect was called "a perspective of feeling" by Horace Lecoq de Boisbaudran, who was well known in Degas' circle.2  Degas' distorted perspective of the room heightens the emotional resonance in the painting.

Although the man which is the dominant figure whose shadow looms up and above, is aiming his controlling male gaze in the woman's direction, there is nothing in his look or casual stance that suggests any kind of a violent commentary.  Even though we can't see the expression on the woman's face, she has turned away from him in such a way that the discord between the two figures becomes obvious. There was a belief at this time that by looking at a person's physiognomy, you could tell about his nature.  Degas did paint the male protagonist's ears pointy referring to the physiognomy of a satyr, which was a man with an insatiable appetite for sex.  The sexual undertones are present in the painting without a certain narrative.

This painting was titled 'the Rape'  after it's first public showing 35 years after it was painted.  Some art historians interpreted it as a literary work, associated with Emile Zola's Therese Raquin.   But according to Susan Sidlauskas in her essay "Resisting Narrative:  The Problem of Edgar Degas's Interior" if there was a tale in Interior, Degas twisted it beyond recognition.3


Edgar Degas did not exhibit this painting and kept it in his possession until 1904 when he sold it at Galerie  Durand-Ruel.  No one seems to know why he painted such a scene or what he was trying to say but the painting does contain elements Degas deemed important. The issue of disconnect, Degas' association of sexuality and art with artifice, incorporating "a perspective of feeling", are all used to great effect in Interior, helping to further defy any kind of a logical explanation for this puzzling painting.   It seems to have a story that wants to be told but Degas refuses to give us the narrative, challenging us in our encounter with the visual phenomena set before us.


1  Susan Sidlauskas, Resisting Narrative:  The Problem of Edgar Degas's Interior, The Art Bulletin December 1993, Volume LXXV number 4, 691
2  Ibid., 686
3  Ibid., 676

Friday, April 22, 2011

Georges Seurat - Le Cirque

Georges Seurat, Le Cirque, 1890
(Musee d'Orsay)
This was Georges Seurat's last painting that he exhibited at the Salon des Independants in 1891 in its unfinished state. He died a couple of days after hanging the painting.  This painting contains all the elements Seurat was interested in and experimenting with,  but we don't know how much further or in which direction he might have gone from here since he died so young, leaving behind his own version of optical blending of color called pointillism.

Jules Cheret, Hippodrome de la PorteMaillot,
Paris Courses,
1890
Le Cirque is a very good example of how Seurat incorporated popular imagery and interpreted the condition of modern society into his work.  He could have looked to one of  Jules Cheret's posters advertising the Paris Courses at the Hippodrome de la Porte Maillot, or a Ball at the Moulin Rouge,  for this  particular painting; some of the figures and colors are almost exact replicas.  Seurat was known to have admired how Gustave Courbet used popular culture as a source for fine art.  This was a time when posters were starting to be used for the advertisement of popular entertainments and Cheret's posters would have been all over Paris.  What Seurat accomplished by breaking down barriers was cause for criticizim for bringing in too much popular culture to his work.

Theatrical subject matters like the circus were also a favorite with Degas, who also might have had an influence on Seurat's selection of this particular motif.



This painting with all its upward moving diagonals and warm colors, all of which would have suggested a happy and uplifting experience, in actuality could have been a critique of spectatorship.  The audience seems to be unresponsive to the spectacle that was taking place in front of their eyes.  This was a time when people of all classes were looking to find entertainments in a city like Paris that in itself had become a spectacle as T. J. Clark called it in his book, The Painting of Modern Life. 
Seurat applied Henry Chevreul's theory of the balancing contrasting colors to create harmony by painting a blue frame to the predominantly yellow color of  this picture.

Observing how Seurat has flattened the picture plane even more than his previous works and the different  points of perspective offered within the painting and the juxtaposition of the different concerns throughout the history of art being incorporated in his own unique vision makes me wonder what was next if he had lived a longer life.

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Cult of Beauty: The Aesthetic Movement 1860-1900




A fascinating exhibit is going on right now at the Victoria & Albert Museum (one of my favorite museums in the world) The concepts introduced are relevant to other artistic movements as well... the obsession with 'Red Hair' for example can be picked up in Degas' series of women at their toilette.

Edgar Degas, The Tub, 1886
(Musee d'Orsay)

Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Edward Hopper - The Painter of American Loneliness

Edward Hopper, Gas, 1940
(Whitney Museum of American Art, New York)
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _Gas_, 1940


My fascination with Edward Hopper began when I read a blogpost on Alberti's Window comparing Hopper's paintings to Gustave Caillebotte's, reasoning that they both worked within the themes of isolation and loneliness.  I got a chance to compare the two artist's work on my trip to Chicago and the argument seemed feasible.
Edward Hopper, Nighthawks, 1942
(Art Institute of Chicago)
Gustave Caillebotte, Paris Street:  Rainy Day, 1877
(Art Institute of Chicago)
Both artists were painting the urban landscape and the alienating nature of modernization.  When considering their paintings of the city, in both instances, a burgeoning city is the backdrop to individuals that are trying to exist within the new norms of modern life.

Edward Hopper, Seven A.M., 1948
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _Seven A.M._, 1948

There was an exhibit at the Whitney Museum in New York, that caught my attention and I finally got a chance to see it before it closed on Sunday.  Here, I was able garner what set Hopper apart from any other painter I knew.  Being one of the quintessential American icons,  his paintings seems to captures this country's soul.


Edward Hopper, Le bistro, 1909
(Whitney Museum of American Art)


When I stood before this painting though I felt like I was closer to the soul of the artist than the city. It seemed like the visualization of one of my own experiences, that of being an outsider in a foreign land.  It's nice but you can not be a part of it, only observe it.

Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _Le Bistro_ or _The Wine Shop_, 1909









Edward Hopper, Early Sunday Morning,
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _Early Sunday Morning_, 1930

Edward Hopper, New York Interior,
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _New York Interior_, 1921
Actually this painting reminded me of Edgar Degas' Interior
Edgar Degas, Interior,1868-1869
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)

Edward Hopper, The Sheridan Theater, 1937
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _The Sheridan Theatre_, 1937

Edward Hopper, Soir Bleu, 194
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _Soir Bleu_, 1914
Edward Hopper, A Woman In the Sun, 1961
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _A Woman in the Sun_, 1961
When I stood before this painting, I finally realized what seemed so familiar about Hopper's paintings, it was a landscape I knew really well.  It was the picture of the bone-chilling loneliness one can only feel in America, where there are beautiful vistas outside of your window, in front of your door but no sign of human life.  He had painted my America... For years, even as I refused to give in to the feeling of isolation, I was always going in search of the sun, first thing in the morning, to warm my soul.

Edward Hopper, Self-Portrait, 1925-30
Whitney Museum of American Art: Watch and Listen: Audio Guides: Edward Hopper, _Self-Portrait_, 1925–30

http://whitney.org/Exhibitions/ModernLife

Wednesday, April 6, 2011

Mary Cassatt - The Bath


Mary Cassatt, The Bath, 1892
(The Art Institute of Chicago)
Here is another painting called The Bath, by one of Degas' friends, Mary Cassatt.  Although this is also a scene of a woman in her daily life, during a private moment, it has some fundamental differences with Degas' The Tub, that are very much gender related.

Edgar Degas, The Tub, 1886
(Musee d'Orsay)
Mary Cassatt was a female artist from the upper classes who according to Degas had lines 'like a man's.'  She owned some of Degas' pastels of women bathing, encouraged some American women to collect them and might have been thinking of him when she made this painting.  The view is up close, from up above, looking down but instead of a prostitute washing herself, it is a mother washing her child.  Certain elements like the intimate experience of a mother and child would be unique only to a female artist. As a general rule, men were not allowed in the nursery.  The reverse would be true for Mary Cassatt as well; she could not invite a prostitute to her studio to paint or even see her in the nude - Cassatt would lose her reputation.  


Cassatt saw an exhibit of Kitagawa Utamaro's prints in 1890 that inspired her to do a portfolio of prints of women in their daily activities.  She originally had men in some of the prints but later she took them out and concentrated only on women.  Her figures in these prints alluded to the Asian type and the dresses patterns were similar to Asian dresses.  The influence of the Japanese woodcut prints is very apparent in this painting.

In this oil on canvas painting, the mother and child's gazes are averted from the viewer looking down at the water in the basin.  Cassatt used her own family members as models for her paintings and the way the mother is holding the child with one hand while washing her feet with the other relays a very natural, tender moment she probably experienced herself.

It is interesting to see the different approaches taken by artists of different genders who were influenced by and represented the same subjects. Degas and Cassatt, both were looking at Japanese prints in depicting women at their daily activities totally absorbed in their intimate occupations.  While Degas' was the detached male gaze getting a peek at a private moment of a woman washing herself, Cassatt's is the tender gaze of a woman who had  intimate knowledge of the scene she was depicting taking place in a space of femininity.


Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Edgar Degas - The Tub

Edgar Degas, The Tub, 1885-1886
(Hill-Stead Museum, CT)
In the 1880's Degas worked on a series of pastels on paper with the subject matter of women at their toilette.   Unlike his earlier pastels, he intended these to be a group so he used store bought boards of the same size establishing a sense of unity.  He exhibited six of these in the last Impressionist show in 1886.
In this group Degas showed women taking their daily ablutions, totally absorbed in their activity, in a cuvette (a shallow tub).  The models' faces and expressions could not be discerned because Degas chose to portray them concentrating on their activity, not looking or acknowledging the viewer in any way.  In so doing he universalized and disassociated them from any particular type of woman and put the viewer in the position of catching a private view of a woman in her most natural and candid moment.  However, the decor, tub and the chair are clues indicating she is of Degas' time.  Also the use of the shallow tub and even her red hair had class associations pointing to her lower class origins.

The subject matter of the women at their toilette was due to the influence of Japanese woodblock prints but Degas' figures are much more modeled than their flat Japanese counterparts.  In these pastels, Degas went back to drawing and to borrowing and transforming ancient art.  Some of the poses in these works recall sculptures from antiquity.  He worked every area of the pastel with chiaroscuro and sharp outlines. Degas felt that drawing allowed him to achieve a richer feel emphasizing line over color.  Even his use of color is very linear but, critics ripped him apart for this and wrote that she looked dirty as well as fat and ugly. His use of red haired prostitutes from their contemporary world instead of allegorical beauties with no time or space specificity must have really upset them.  Flaming red hair was associated with sexuality and passion and helped the viewers to identify the figures as prostitutes.  The women look uncomfortable and he was accused of being cruel and debasing women by having them pose this way.  One 19th century critic even said that he was taking down the enshrined woman.

Degas said "my women are simple, honest creatures who are concerned with nothing beyond their physical occupations... it is as if you were looking through a keyhole." With this statement he seems to establish the artlessness of the models, at the same time emphasizing the male gaze as the dominant view point.  

Friday, March 18, 2011

Edgar Degas and Mary Cassatt- Two Artist's Gender Related Differing Views

                
Edgar Degas, Ballerina and Lady with a Fan, 1855                                        Mary Cassatt, At the Opera, 1879
           (Philadelphia Museum of Art)                                                                                  (Boston Museum of Fine Arts)

Although there are only two women painters amongst the famous Impressionists, their different approaches in accordance with the feminine points of view, to the same subjects as their male counterparts is refreshing.  Mary Cassatt was an American artist from a wealthy family, working in Paris.  She became friends with and was invited to exhibit with the Impressionists  by Degas.  He was even reported to have said " No woman, has the right to draw like that."  Being a woman artist from upper class society had one major drawback and that was the spaces of modernity she couldn't depict because she didn't have access to them.  The theater and the opera were two places of entertainment that could accommodate both proper ladies as well as men.  

These two paintings by Edgar Degas and Mary Cassatt both are a discourse about looking, spectatorship and dominance.  The main difference between the two is who is doing the looking and does the one being looked at have any power over the situation.  In Degas' Ballerina and Lady with a Fan, although a woman is sitting in the front of the balcony watching the ballerina perform for her, she is also dominated by the male viewer who would be sitting right behind, looking over her shoulder.  

At this time, ballet was an interlude in an opera.  The sitting arrangements at the boxes over the stage with the privileged view were always occupied by women in the front row and men in the back for protection.  In Degas' painting, we the viewers are in the position of the male spectator, which was also the artist's view.  By the use of a compressed space, Degas has created a sense of dominance; the lady dominates over the ballerina who is working, dancing for her while the male viewer is watching the ballerina and his surroundings dominating over the whole scene.  In Mary Cassatt's At the Opera, however, the viewer is beside instead of above and behind the lady and there is a sense of space around the female spectator.  

According the Griselda Pollock social spaces were policed by men watching women, positioning the spectator outside the painting.  In Cassatt's painting we can see the actual man who is doing the policing in the balcony to the woman's right.  Contrary to Degas' female spectator who is holding her opera glasses in her hand, we see a lady more actively engaged with looking in Mary Cassatt's painting because she is holding her binoculars to her eyes and even leaning forward to get a better look.  She does not acknowledge the gaze aimed in her direction, which confirms his right to look and appraise.1

The very proper lady in Cassatt's At the Opera, in a black dress that covers her completely from neck to toe is dressed for a matinée.  She is also wearing a hat and gloves, the only bit of skin visible is her face and neck.      Since the Degas takes place in the evening the lady's dress with the open shoulders would be considered normal- her arms and shoulders would be the only places she would expose.  On the other hand, the ballet dancers, exposing their arms and legs, would be objectified and considered sexual commodities. This was also reinforced because of their origins from the lower classes while the ladies are from the upper classes.

The main differences come into being, I think in how the different genders choose to approach the process of looking and spectatorship.  The female artist, although acknowledges her subject is being regarded by a male gaze, she depicts her as having some power of ignoring it by watching the performance herself.   Meanwhile, in the male artist's painting  the ballerina is on stage displayed for the male gaze, and the lady with the fan, although herself is a spectator, is positioned in a space that puts her under the dominant gaze of the male sitting behind her, giving neither subject any control over her faith what so ever.  

Edgar Degas - In a Cafe (The Absinthe Drinker)

Edgar Degas, In a Cafe (The Absinthe Drinker) 1875-1876
(Musee d'Orsay)
Here is a painting by Edgar Degas, which at first sight, seems to be a portrayal of another aspect of modernity - two individuals, sitting side by side, in a cafe, completely disconnected from one another, not communicating in any way, wallowing in their isolation.  Typical of Impressionist paintings, it looks like a snapshot of a scene anyone might run into on the street, a slice of life.  The subject is one impressionists are very interested in depicting, that of the urban lifestyle lived in the cafes.

The influence of Japanese prints that Degas collected, can be seen in the placement of the  table in the front, at an odd angle that is blocking the viewers way into the picture. The geometric shapes of the tables that lead us into the composition and the placement of the woman almost slightly off center can also be attributed to Japanese prints. The tables are actually geometric shapes that don't have legs with a folded newspaper forming a bridge between the two.

Degas takes on the role of the artist/reporter observing the scene without making any kind of a moral commentary, he even signs his name on the newspaper with the baton, in the front. He gives us the life in the cafe as it is, noting problematic issues of the day along the way.  The drink in front of the woman is known to be absinthe due to its light green color and the water jug sitting on the table next to her.  She looks frazzled, her shoulders stooped, her clothing and hat seem to be in disarray, her feet apart. Degas' use of brown and umber tones adds to her bedraggled appearance. A desolate figure, one of the lost souls who had no life outside of the cafe.  The whole canvas is worked in earth tones with a muted, limited pallet adding to the sense of despair.  Women at cafes and drinking was a big issue of the day and absinthe particularly was frowned upon and later prohibited because of it's hallucinogenic, addicting qualities.  Emile Zola had written a story about a woman who became an alcoholic which horrified the public.  The man leaning on the table completely oblivious to the woman, has a brown drink in a tall footed glass in front of him which was mazagran, a coffee that was drunk to cure a hangover. We can tell it is morning by the light entering form the right side, so they may have been here all night.

Degas carefully composed this scene of real life and painted it in his studio with an actress and a bohemian artist from the Impressionists' circle posing for him as models.  He got criticized for his use of  recognizable individuals as degenerates and according to Musee d'Orsay's website he publicly had to declare that they were not alcoholics.

There is a connection between this painting and the naturalism literary school, which Emile Zola was a part of. Zola started a serial publication, in the spring on 1876, of a scandalous novel about a laundress's slide into alcoholism.1  Both Degas and Zola were telling the dismaying stories of modern society.  In a Cafe, is Degas' detached observation of a contemporary problem that started with the Second Empire in France.  

1  Robert L. Herbert, Impressionism - Art, Leisure & Parisian Society, (Yale University Press, 1988) 74

Wednesday, March 16, 2011

Edgar Degas - Portrait of Henri Michel-Levy

Edgar Degas, Portrait of Henri Michel-Levy, 1878-1879
(Museu Calouste Gulbenkian, Lisbon, Portugal)
Degas was known to exchange portraits with his artist friends. This is a portrait of his friend, Henri Michel-Levy, although here, he is not represented as an artist dominating over his studio.  Instead of the traditional way of depicting him working at his easel, Degas has him leaning against the wall with his hands in his pockets.  We can deduce this space is Henri Michel-Levy's studio because the paintings on the walls are known to be his  paintings.   Only the box open in the front with a pallet and  brushes attests to his profession as an artist.  Upon closer inspection, the odd shaped mannequin by the artist's side on the floor can be picked out as the figure in the painting hanging on the left. This is Degas' way of reinforcing how artist's setup their compositions by using artifice plus the fact that these paintings were made in the studio, using props and not in plen air with real models. 


The influence of Japonism is apparent because the objects in the foreground transition the viewer into the painting as can be found in Japanese prints.  In this painting the pallet and brushes are the first objects the viewer encounters before observing Degas' choice of the subject represented off-center in an odd angle.


This little painting, Portrait of Henri Michel-Levy, might be taken as the perfect visual example of Degas' theory of art being artifice. 

Edgar Degas - The Bellelli Family (Family Portrait)

Edgar Degas, The Bellelli Family, 1858-1867
(Musee d'Orsay)


























Degas was living in Italy and completing his artistic training when he painted this Family Portrait.  Degas' Aunt Laura, her husband Gennaro Bellelli and their two daughters, Guiliana and Giovanna are represented in their rented house in Florence where they were at exile because of Gennaro's involvement in a political plot back at their home in Naples.  


Although at this time, the tradition of posing for portraits was an unsmiling demeanor, the palpable tension separating each member of the family is still a little peculiar.   There is no sense of togetherness or hierarchy where the mother stands tall, a severe expression in her face with the two daughters by her side, while the father sits off to the side, his back turned to the viewer.  Laura has a lack hand on one girl's shoulder and the other on the desk near but not touching the other daughter.  The husband and wife are at the farthest corners of the picture plane, not even connecting thorough their gazes.  As a matter of fact, there is a collective distraction where all the figures are looking at different directions.  The little portrait of Laura's father hanging on the wall behind her is calling attention to her genealogy and not to her husband's.  The father is in profile and his chair blocks the way so even the viewer can not connect with him.


Degas further emphasizes the  sense of disconnect by the cool colors in his pallet as well as his outlines.  He uses a lot of blues and only a little bit of yellow in the carpet to add dynamism.  Degas' aunt and her daughters are in black while her husband, in gray, does not match them.


Laura had to marry Gennaro as a last resort because her father had not been satisfied with any of her other suitors until she was 28.  She was extremely unhappy in her marriage and shared her misgivings with Degas.  There is even speculation that she might be pregnant in this painting, hinting at marital rape.


There was a lot of concern at this time about the state of affairs in middle class and upper-middle class families.  People were becoming more mobile and not living or working together all the time, on a farm.  The government emphasized the importance of procreation and the family where people could get the proper education, after the devastating defeat of the Franco-Prussian war and the upheaval of the Commune. All these factors were affecting families and Degas, especially, was obsessed with the disconnect in relationships.  His family portraits all share the same, odd, dissociated figures.  Ironically, his brothel images are a more unified group than his family portraits.


Degas painted this interior scene because he could not paint outdoors due to a problem with his eyes.  The whole composition is artifice because it has been very deliberately constructed by Degas. He emphasized the bigger social issues by the placement of the figures, the use of bold colors, and the horizontal and vertical planes in this composition.  


Even though Degas used the mirror in the back  to open up the space, allowing a little bit of light to come inside the room, this still couldn't dispel the general gloomy mood of this painting.  This family in their rented house far away form their own home, with faces devoid of all expression was Degas' direct experience.  I think in representing them in this manner he not only allowed what he knew of their private situation to be displayed but also used this pretext to touch upon a major concern of society which in turn makes The Bellelli Family a picture of modernity.

Edgar Degas - Odd Man Out

Edgar Degas, Two Dancers on a Stage, 1874
(The Courtland Gallery, London)
"Art is Vice. You don't marry it.  You rape it.  Whoever says Art says Artifice."   Edgar Degas

I grew up with a print of this painting hanging on my wall.  To me it represented everything that was elegant and lovely.  I went to bed dreaming I would be just like these ballerinas when I grew up.  Ignorance is bliss?  Maybe, maybe not... It is hard to reconcile my little girl dreams with the above quote...

Although Degas was friends and exhibited with the impressionists, in reality he hated improvised compositions, rapid brushwork and plein air painting.  He believed that art is artifice; it should be based on the real world but not be an exact replica of it. He set his compositions with deliberate arrangements.  Due to a problem with his eyes, he was extremely sensitive to light and could not paint outdoors.

Edgar Degas, Portrait of Monseuir and Madame Eduoard Manet,1868-1869  

Degas thought of himself as the artist-journalist and the scenes he depicted were little snapshots of life in the streets of Paris, at the ballet, the cafes and the races. Similar to Manet, he was the quintessential flaneur, going around, observing and making commentary about the spectacle that was Paris and its inhabitants.  He painted mostly interiors and very few landscapes, aside from horse races.  Three quarter of his work was about women, he was obsessed with them but never married.  He was also known to be a misogynistic and anti-semitic.  Even though he had some odd notions, the ambiguity and the sense of disconnect present in his work and his unique perspectives are so intriguing that one can't help but be fascinated with him.

Edgar Degas, The Green Dancer, 1880
(Thyssen Bornemizsa Museum, Madrid)
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...