Showing posts with label 19th Century. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 19th Century. Show all posts

Saturday, September 24, 2016

How preserving cultural heritage sites can help to combat ignorance and fight biased politics

Did you know that one of the oldest sites of human settlement in the Americas, from 15,000 years ago, Cactus Hill, is in Virginia?

The world these days seems to be in a state of constant chaos, with pain and suffering everywhere we turn. Instead of coming together to ease the suffering of those in need, we seem to be more divided than ever.  A big part of the problem is the manipulation of people with half-truths or flat-out lies by the so-called leaders of their own countries. If there is a population of ignorant or even disenfranchised people, those who want to get elected or stay in power are ready with their divisive politics to "divide and conquer." People are fed biased, skewed narratives according to the ideology of those in or near power. While in America, the narrative of America is for Americans can be heard in half the political arenas across the country, half way across the world, in Turkey, politicians appropriating the Ottoman culture in accordance with their vision, are misleading an ignorant populace towards an imported religious ideology that wants to curtail women's rights and impose archaic bans on people's social lives. Although this type of Islam is not the culture of Anatolia, it is being sold as such to the uneducated, the gullible and the innocent believer. Looking at the disheartening political debates taking place all around us, some might ask "Is it possible to combat ignorance and racism?" I argue it is...  by preserving, sharing and respecting cultural heritage.

Abdulmecid Efendi, Last Capliph and 37th Head of the Ottoman Dynasty, Beethoven in the Harem
(Istanbul Resim ve Heykel Muzesi)
(Istanbul Museum of Art and Sculpture) 
In a world full of so many urgent problems, people sometimes have a hard time understanding the emphasis we put on privileging cultural heritage preservation. But the relevance and importance of cultural heritage can be observed all around us, in the daily newspapers, on social media, in what is happening around the world everyday.
I was inspired to write this post after reading numerous articles in the Turkish newspapers about a Symposium being organized at the Parliament, to honor the 34th Ottoman Sultan, Abdulhamid II. Now, some might say, that is a Turkish issue... It has nothing to do with us... Why should we care about this? The specific case is such a great example of guiding the ignorant and the disenfranchised towards a certain ideology, that I think it is relevant to all of us around the world, no matter what religion, nationality or culture we may come from.

Label for Elif Raki produced without anise and referred to as "Plain Raki"
The current speaker of the Turkish Parliament, Ismail Kahraman, during his announcement about the Symposium organized for the occasion of Sultan Abdulhamid II's birthday, is reported as saying:
Unfortunately, history and cultural heritage is not known, especially the youth do not know it, they have been deliberately made to forget, we have a debt to our Sultan Abdulhamid.
To the outsider, this may seem an innocuous statement, but anyone who is familiar with Turkish politics will know the real meaning behind the statement. Sultan Abdulhamid II (r. 1876-1909) is a controversial figure in Turkish politics, being revered as Abdulhamid Han, due to his pan-Islamic ideologies for the Ottoman empire by the conservative Islamists in power today, and remembered for his one-man, autocratic rule, severe paranoia, extensive network of spies who reported and persecuted many innocents by everyone else. This, of course is not the correct way of examining a historical figure but it summarizes the two points of view and strengthens my argument towards the importance of cultural heritage.

Label for "Üzüm Kizi" Raki, produced in Istanbul, 1880s
by the Head Chamberlain of Sultan Abdulhamid II, Ragip Pasha

While the current ruling party, AKP is busy with the apotheosis of Abdulhamid II, they are concurrently trying to smirch the reputation and erase the memory of Ataturk, the founding father of modern, secular Turkey. Although Ataturk's habit of imbibing and entertaining regularly, where issues regarding the new Republic were discussed, are known by all and do not cast a flicker of a shadow on his character or deeds, AKP has been focusing on this as the evidence of the corruption of the foundation of the Republic. They have been calling him a drunk to insult not only Ataturk but everything that he represents. The sweet irony in all this is, that the first raki, beer and champagne production started in the Ottoman empire with the seal and approval of Abdulhamid II...you know the "orthodox" Sultan as opposed to the "drunk" general who had dinner parties every night. It was the Head Chamberlain and one of the ministers of finance in Abdulhamid's court, Ragip Pasha, who opened the first raki production facility in the Ottoman empire. According to his grandson, Abdulhamid was known to prefer rum since it was made from sugar and not specifically prohibited in the Q'uran. Hypocrite or not, this only shows that the Ottoman Sultan was just like any other powerful man of his time... drinking, dancing, watching the performance of European opera companies and even frolicking with cabaret dancers... While one cannot help but be amused by the irony, none of these facts change Abdulhamid's deeds, the good along with the evil; however this post is not about Abdulhamid, but combating ignorance and manipulation of those who deify him, through the preservation of cultural heritage.

Bomonti Brewery, opened 1888-1890, Istanbul

So, what does cultural heritage have to do with this, some might ask. It has everything to do with it.

Those who blindly believe in the rhetoric of populist politicians may disbelieve the facts that are presented to them as newspaper articles or scholarly papers but as they say, seeing is believing. The beauty and significance of material culture is that they stand before us as irrefutable facts. We had such a great opportunity with the Bomonti Brewery in Istanbul, the first modern brewery that opened in 1890 and continued to be in production until 1991. The site was recently renovated as an art, culture and entertainment space. Unfortunately, I was not able to visit it but from the promotion material and the media write ups I have read, it looks to be a carefully planned out space with everything in one complex, from restaurants, exhibition spaces and a bookstore to even a jazz club that utilized the historic texture, merely, as an ornamental backdrop. In light of these latest events, I can't help but ruminate why they could not have preserved it as the very important industrial heritage site that it was.

Aluyulala Hususi Raki Label
The Bomonti Brewery could have been the perfect space to set up a museum on the social life of 19th century Istanbul, highlighting minority narratives, providing information about the neighborhoods and the people who lived in the area. It could have been a space to highlight Industrialization in 19th century Istanbul. It could have been many things but instead of preserving the Industrial Heritage and utilizing it as a space for the dissemination of knowledge about our common past as the descendants of the Ottomans, it was handed over to developers for a venue that will probably be accessible only by the rich, secular, "marginal" (as the President often refers to them) and the few.

Bomonti Beer Gardens
The above example can be adapted to any country with leaders using racist narratives to rally support for their outdated, 19th century political ideologies. We should not judge historical events or figures anachronistically but we should learn from and improve upon them.  By being aware of and understanding the past, we can protect ourselves from fallacy of politicians and engender a better future. That, is why we need to prioritize the preservation of cultural heritage in all of its forms.



Sunday, April 17, 2016

Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun - a Female Academician

Vigée Le Brun, Self-Portrait, 1790
(Gallerie degli Uffizi)
Art history is full of great male artists while we hear very little of the successful women who managed the almost impossible feat of carving out careers where no opportunities existed. Élisabeth Louise Vigée Le Brun was one such artist who was not only the favorite portraitist of Marie Antoinette, the queen of France, but also to many notable aristocrats, artists, musicians and poets throughout 18th - 19th century Europe.  There is currently an exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, Vigée Le Brun: Woman Artist in Revolutionary France, which displays 80 works from around the world of the artist who had a successful career in one of the most turbulent periods of European history.

Self_Portrait in Traveling Costume, 1789-90
(Private Collection)
This exhibition should be visited on site or online not only to view beautiful works of art from the Rococo period but also as an inspirational tale of one woman's journey of survival and success under some of the most unfavorable circumstances. The Met has a great exhibition page (link) that has all the works on display as well as the audioguide that is available in the museum. Of course nothing can compare to experiencing these works in person, but if you can not make it to the museum, this is a really great alternative. Instead of giving an overview of the exhibit, I want to take this opportunity to focus on the obstacles Vigee Le Brun had to overcome in order to become the celebrated artist of her time.

Vigee-LeBrunn, Peace Bringing Back Abundance,  1780,  exhibited at Salon of 1783
(Musee du Louvre)
This was the reception piece Vigee-LeBrun submitted into the Academie to be admitted as a member.  The French Royal Academy did not accept female artists as members on the premises of their supposed inferiority to the male artists but between its foundation in the 17th century and the revolution, a few women were allowed within its hallowed halls.  Out of the total of 450 members  there were between 12 to 15 who were female, and those would only would be accepted four at a time.  Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun along with Adelaide Labille-Guiard were accepted into the Academie in 1783 only after the deaths of two female artists.

Etienne Vigée, 1773, painted at 18 prior to joining the Academie de Saint-Luc
(Saint Louis Art Museum)
Prior to their acceptance into the academy both Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun along with Adelaide Labille-Guiardthey were members of the Academie de Saint-Luc which was the ancient artist's guild.  One of the original reasons for establishing the Academie de peinture et de sculpture was to distinguish real artists from the artisans and provide them with the necessary teachings besides drawing and painting to allow them to become the artistic geniuses they were.  Also the Academie was state sponsored and artist got paid by the government so they could create without being beholden to trade. Members of the Academy of Saint-Luc were frowned upon because of their involvement with the trade. The Allegory of Poetry was one of the works from Vigée Le Brun's first exhibition at the Academie de Saint-Luc.

Allegory of Poetry, 1774
(Henry and Catherine Robet)

Although Vigee-LeBrun aspired to be a history painter, the most prestigious of the genres, she could only be accepted as genre painter, two steps lower than male academicians.  Since women could not work from live models and were not educated in anatomy, they could not become history painters which would preclude them from having all the privileges the male artists gained like studio space and an allowance.  Although it was impossible for her to be a history painter, Vigee-LeBrun still produced a work of art that could actually very well have been accepted as such.

Study for Abundance, 1780
(Private Collection)
In Peace Bringing Back Abundance, Vigee-LeBrun represents two allegorical figures using traditional symbols, Peace on the right garbed in darker colors is wearing a crown of laurels on her dark hair, and carrying an olive branch, while Abundance is blond wearing white and gold and bearing a cornucopia full of fruits, flowers in her hair and holding ears of wheat, her fertility is pronounced with her exposed breast.  France had been a supporter of the American War of Revolution and this painting underscores that involvement.

Vigee-LeBrun showed incredible artistry in this piece but she was admitted into the Academie with reluctance plus pressure from the crown, because of her husband's profession of being an art dealer.   It seems the Academie did all they can to try to dissuade female artists from joining their ranks but one or two exceptional artists still managed to get by.

- This is an edited version, with additional content, of a prior post that was written in October 2011.

Saturday, June 9, 2012

Berthe Morisot -The Wet Nurse

Berthe Morisot, The Wet Nurse and Julie, 1880
(Private Collection)


Pierre-Auguste Renoir, Mother Nursing Her Child, 1886
(Private Collection)
Art history is full of female mavericks that not only overcame their gendered roles by actually producing works that went down in history but also made bold statements quite contrary to the popular culture and beliefs of the society they were living in.  I was watching the latest rendition of Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre for the big screen last night where I was reminded once again of how incredibly modern and wonderfully askew a story it was.  It is so refreshing to be witness to a strong female character who not only overcomes her "Tale of Woe" but also comes back at the end to rescue the love of her life, Mr. Rochester who is now debilitated.  She has become rich while he has become blind...Jane Eyre is the veritable knight  in shining armor or the prince on the white horse charging to rescue the damsel in distress...

Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Happy Birthday Mary Cassatt - A True Feminist

Mary Cassatt, A Woman and A Girl Driving, 1881
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)

Mary Cassatt was a maverick among her peers that broke all the conventions of 19th century society while living a perfectly respectable life (which was the most important thing at her day and age) and enjoying success and acceptance as an American Impressionist artist in Paris.   When we are still discussing gender discrimination and social gendered roles, Cassatt managed to work as a professional artist, exhibit with the Impressionists and  leave behind an exceptional legacy for all American artists to follow.  Some might argue at this point that she was born into a privileged background allowing her to pursue her career as an artist in Paris but  I would like to point out that she was from a wealthy family in Philadelphia which was a conservative area with very strict expectations from a woman of her position.  Like all women of her class, she was expected to marry and have children, not go traipsing about in Europe learning to paint and displaying her talents for all the world to see.  

Saturday, February 18, 2012

A Transcendent Experience - Philipp Otto Runge's Morning

Philipp Otto Runge, Morning, 1808
(Hamburger Kunsthalle)

"A man should hear a little music, read a little poetry, and see a fine picture everyday of his life, in order that worldly cares may not obliterate the sense of the beautiful which God has implanted in the human soul."
- Johann Wolfgang Goethe




I have been obsessed with Philipp Otto Runge's Morning, ever since I first heard of it in a German Romanticism class.  I think there was something about it that resonated with what I was familiar with in Islamic manuscript painting.  The style and symmetry of Runge's composition, the expressive use of  color and elements from nature, and especially the frame, all added to the similarities  between the two traditions in my personal opinion.  I should probably admit that most of these observations may be a bit cursory and although the painted frame reminiscent of Islamic illuminations is an integral part of the painting in Morning, it is interpreted in the Renaissance tradition, as validating this as a work of art or the open window to the world outside.  

Tuesday, December 27, 2011

Following Ingres' Line of Beauty at the Met

Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres, La Grande Odalisque, 1814
(Musee du Louvre)
When I look at a work of art, it is a very personal experience that far surpasses just analyzing the artists style, composition and subject matter, it is a connection with that era, with that artist.  In studying the great masters, art history classes tend to concentrate on their most famous works in order to convey the artist's most significant achievements but looking at slides or pictures of these grande works on the internet does not appease my longing for a more personal experience. Luckily, I live near New York City, which enables me to realize my penchant for personally engaging with most of the great works of art I study.  This semester, I took a class called  "Revolution to Realism: European Painting 1760-1860"  which for the most part covered French artists, Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres being one of the giants of this period.

Ingres, The Bather of Valpincon,1808
(Musee du Louvre)

Of course, most of Ingres' oeuvre is now housed at the Louvre Museum in Paris but I was able to encounter some of his works at the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York.  Some of Ingres most famous works are his Oriental nudes which are incredibly fascinating due to his unique style of combining Classicism with Mannerism.  There is an almost photographic quality in some parts of his works with the amount of detail he portrays with such precision while simultaneously distorting the figures to suit his purpose.  This is especially apparent in his sensual nudes who seem to posses extremely elongated bodies and no muscles, just soft, smooth flesh. The critics who saw these nudes at the Salon noted that he added two or three extra vertebra to these figures and it was actually impossible for them to stand or walk.  The sense of weightlessness that can be observed in the Bather of Valpincon and the impossible position of the Grande Odalisque are all part of the fantasy Ingres creates about an exotic world of his imagination. Although he produced many Oriental themed paintings, Ingres never actually traveled to the Middle East or encounter a real Harem or an Odalisque in his life.  His nudes appealed to the Western male viewer because these women were there for male consumption and even their feet which didn't look like they had touched the ground conveyed the message of being kept for the pleasure of men.  Ingres used the S-shaped Line of Beauty to enhance his compositions to great effect.  

Being a Classicist in the Davidian tradition, Ingres believed contours were the most important element in a painting, that even clouds should have contours.  He used closed forms where following the contour of the figure, the viewer can go all the way around the figure to arrive at the point where they started; this is very obvious in his nudes.  I was able to follow his contours first hand as I stood before the Odalisque in Grisaille, at the Met, "an unfinished repetition of the celebrated Grande Odalisque of 1814" according the museum label. In black and white, the soft contours of the body are enhanced more clearly and Ingres' reputation as a master of realism is reinforced. Also lacking the intricate details and lavish colors, Ingres' Classicism is better identified with the stark reality of his lines and shadows and the perfectly smooth surface of his canvas. The sense of quiet that permeates The Bather of Valpincon, can also be felt in this painting; the lack of noise is one of the qualities that captured my attention first.  This is a great work in learning the flow of the brush of such a master and deciphering how he worked.  

Ingres painted Le Grande Odalisque while he was in Rome and studying the masters, especially Raphael whom he was fascinated with; as a matter of fact, the profile of the figure was likened to something Raphael would paint.  I think finding a Raphael that most closely resembles this figure would be delightful, but that is going to have to be a project for another day. For now, I leave you with Ingres and his voluptuous nudes...

Jean Auguste Dominique Ingres and Workshop, Odalisque in Grisaille, 1824-34
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)

Sunday, December 4, 2011

A Friendship Portrait by Friedrich Overbeck

Friedrich Overbeck, Portrait of Franz Pforr, 1810
(Nationalgalerie, Berlin)
Depending on the cognizance of the viewer, symbolism in art can be regarded as either captivating or aggravating, but incredibly informative nonetheless.   I recently read a fascinating post about the symbolism in Titian's Sacred and Profane Love which the author, H. Niyazi, refers to as a template to approaching a mystery painting.  In my estimation it is a great guide even the uninitiated can benefit from in deciphering the wonderful, and sometimes, ambiguous world of art history.  Romanticism in the German Speaking World is another time in history where understanding the iconography is vital in truly understanding and appreciating the art and the artists of that particular movement.  It may be a bit of a paradox to start a blog post about one of the leaders of the Nazarenes with a reference to a painting by Titian, but muse, as they say, is a strange mistress.  


The Nazarenes were a highly individualized group of students from the Vienna Academy of Art, in 1809, who were opposed to the Classical teachings of the academy and believed inspiration could be found in medieval and Christian art as well as in their Germanic ancestry.  They revered the masters of the Quattrocento, especially Raphael and the 16th century German artist Durer. They sought to apply to their work the views of art and its social role expressed in influential books of the previous generation such as Wilhelm Wackenroder's Herzensergiessungen eines kunstliebenden Klosterbruders (Outpourings of an Art-Loving Monk). Led by Friedrich Overbeck and Franz Pforr, they swore an oath of brotherhood and formed the Lukasbund (the brotherhood of St Luke) after the patron saint of medieval and Renaissance artisans.  The principle of their program was that art must serve only the highest ends (religion) and never the vanity of courts or wealthy individuals.1


Instead of copying the works of the masters, as instructed at the academy, they believed in working as autonomous artists in order to develop their own individual talents. Overbeck stated that "even if he did not learn to use paint like a Titian, or become as expert in chiaroscuro as a Correggio, the important thing was that he become an Overbeck." They took nature as their true model and each artist followed his own inclinations in pursuit of their common ideals.2  


The members of the Lukasbund  came to regard illusionistic painting as the mark of the artist's subservience to the whims of their patron who wanted them to represent the world as they wanted to be seen.  According to Lionel Gossman, their goal was to reveal the essential truth of things as perceived by the artist's imagination.  Aiming to produce art that is more than pleasing or ornamental they started to use elements to refute the illusion of depth.  In drawing, contour and line were emphasized with a minimum of modeling and their subjects were  placed parallel to the surface of the work.  Pforr and Overbeck had developed a theory of color symbolism that they used as an important component of their compositions but color (local color) was always considered to be secondary to line. They wanted to represent the essential forms of things rather than what they perceived to be their passing appearances.3


In 1810, after the French invasion of Vienna, Overbeck and several other members of the Lukasbund moved to Rome with hopes of finding a very pure community where artists would be welcome.  They set up their community in an abandoned monastery where they proceeded to live like monks, sleeping in little cells, painting, eating sparsely, growing their hair and wearing loose robes - all of which earned them the derogatory nickname "Nazarenes".


The Portrait of Franz Pforr painted by Friedrich Overbeck intended as a friendship portrait (freundschaftsbild) full of symbolic iconography could be used as a visual aid in understanding the unique concepts and ideals of the two artists.  Overbeck wrote to one of his Lukasbruder describing the portrait:
    
     "He is standing in ancient German garb at an open Gothic window, framed with stone-carved ornaments and surrounded by grapevines.  One looks into a window, where on the opposite side in the background is sitting a young woman busy with knitting and reading in a devotional book.  In front of her on the table are lilies in a vessel and in the window sits a falcon on his perch; in the back one looks down on a Gothic town and beyond that out on the sea.  The whole is meant to represent him in the situation he would be happiest in..."


 According to Helmut Nickel in his review of the work for the Metropolitan Museum Journal, the church spires resemble St. Stephen's in Vienna and the distant seashore and towering cliffs most likely those of the Sorrento peninsula, near Naples.4 The juxtaposition of a medieval German townscape and an Italian coastline points again to the union of Raphael and Durer, "Italia" and "Germania," and, at the same time, to friendship between the Italianate Overbeck and the Germanic Pforr.5  Nickel also mentions the red-wine color of the medieval type of tunic Pforr is wearing, a hue used to indicate the "saintliness" of the wearer according to the color symbolism developed by the two artists.6  Besides the Gothic Cathedral and the color red,there are other references to Christianity as well, including the lily and the lectern by the woman both attributes of the Virgin Mary, the grapevine symbolizing the Eucharist and the cross and skull, Pforr's emblem of the victory of faith over death. The domesticated falcon sitting on his perch could be symbolizing hope or the traditional Christian symbol of gentile converted to Christianity.


The woman in the background is identified as part of the ideal Pforr was referring to in a letter to his Lukasbund friends explaining his wish to spend his life as a Schlachtenmaler  (painter of battle scenes) in a room hung with paintings of bygone ages and with a lovely wife sitting at a table nearby occupied with some domestic work.5 The woman's coloring is also signifying gentleness.


Hans Sues von Kulmbach, Girl Making a Garland, 
reverse of Head of young Man, 1510
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)
There is also a cat in the foreground rubbing up to Pforr's arm that seems to have a more problematic explanation. Lionel Gossman suggests in its slightly forward position, the cat is gently related to the female figure behind the sitter. The cat and the falcon are both thought to be the symbols of wilderness tamed and restrained. It could also represent the devil overcome by the Virgin in reference to Guilo Romano's Raphael-inspired Madonna with the Cat.  Although there is no proof of Overbeck seeing the Girl Making a Garland, which was in Vienna and Naples when he was there, Helmut Nickel suggests that he might have had this in mind when he painted the demure female figure sewing behind Pforr.  He also references the inscription of the scroll ,"I bind with forget-me-nots", as a perfect source of inspiration for this friendship portrait. Finally, it might also be Pforr's actual pet that Overbeck gave a place of honor.7


The Romantic notion that art is not supposed to represent reality by imitation but signify the sole of the subject by transformation is achieved masterfully in Portrait of Franz Pforr.  Overbeck and Pforr wanted to purify art from all the illusionistic influences of Renaissance and in its stead wanted to produce what they considered to be a clear and pure art that came from earlier influences in 14th and 15th centuries, literary works of German Romantic writers and above all from their imagination.  There is a sense of mystery and playfulness in deciphering their works which also happen to be intellectually engaging.  Their unusual pictorial elements combined with synthesized ideas from varying sources makes me wonder what the experience of the viewer unfamiliar with the iconography would be though.




1  Lionel Gossman, "BEYOND MODERN:  The Art of the Nazarens,"  Common Knowledge 14.1, (2008) p. 60-61
2  Ibid., p. 64
3  Ibid., p. 68
4  Helmut Nickel, "The Bride and the Cat:  A Possible Source for Overbeck's Freundschaftsbild of Franz Pforr" Metropolitan Museum Journal, Vol. 27, (1992), pp. 183-187
5  Lionel Gossman, "BEYOND MODERN:  The Art of the Nazarens,"  Common Knowledge 14.1, (2008) p. 90
6  Ibid.,p. 185
7. Helmut Nickel, "The Bride and the Cat:  A Possible Source for Overbeck's Freundschaftsbild of Franz Pforr"Metropolitan Museum Journal, Vol. 27,  (1992), pp. 185

Saturday, October 15, 2011

Three Paintings from the Salon of 1787

Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun, Marie-Antoinette and her Children, Salon of 1787
(Versailles)



Adelaide Labille-Guiard, Madame Adelaide of France, Salon of 1787
(Palace of Versailles)
These two enormous paintings hung side by side at the Salon of 1787.  While Adelaide Labille-Guiard's Portrait of the King's Aunt was lauded as a big success, Vigee-LeBrun's portrait of Marie-Antoinette was so severely criticized that it had to be taken down in two days.  People were complaining about everything they could find, even the gilded frame saying this was where all the money of France was going to.  Considering Jacques-Louis David's Death of Socrates was also hanging at the same Salon, it is very interesting to compare the different styles, and the social and political meanings being presented within the same year.


Jacques-Louis David, The Death of Socrates, 1787
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)


Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun - a Self Portrait within the Teachings of Rousseau

Elisabeth Louise VigeeLe-Brunn, Self Portrait with her Daughter, Julie,  1786
(Musee du Louvre)
It is facinating to see how an artist depicts one's self in portraits, when she has total control of the image she wants to present to the world.  Vigee-LeBrun's Self Portrait with her Daughter Julie is a very interesting form of self-representation especially for someone who is trying to establish her identity as a serious academician.  Instead of the usual way of representing herself at her easel with the tools of her trade, Vigee-Le-Brun portrays herself holding her daughter in a loving embrace, the mother and child, a perfect picture of contentment.

Paintings from the era before abstraction are great models to decipher the concerns and beliefs of the society for whose consumption the works were meant for.  This self-portrait can be seen as a  reflection of the enlightened ideas of Jean Jacques Rousseau in 18th century France.  Rousseau's book Emile, a manual on the education of children and the nature of man, very clearly spelled out the best way to bring up a child as well as the roles befitting each gender.  He argued the best place for a woman was in the home, taking care of her children which was detrimental to the well-being of the child.   Rousseau, who was passionately against the concept of using wet-nurses, the common practice of the aristocracy, preached breastfeeding one's own child instead. According to Rousseau, the bond established between mother and child had social consequences affecting society as a whole.

Vigee-LeBrun, Marie-Antoinette and her Children,
1789
(Versailles)
Vigee-LeBrun must have composed this portrait with Rousseau's ideals in mind, showing to the world, that she was a nurturing mother as well as an enlightened artist.

The portrait Marie-Antoinette and her Children  is definitely recalling Rousseau's sentiments.   Marie-Antoinette who was dubbed "Madame Deficit" is no longer a queen in her regalia but a mother surrounded by her children and an empty crib, reminding her people of the child she had lost, a way to get French people's empathy.  Unfortunately, the country had been suffering for too long, people starving, with Marie-Antoinette the most easily identifiable target that even portraits such as these were not enough to save her from the Guillotine.

Adelaide Labille-Guilard - Self-Portrait with Two Pupils

Adelaide Labille-Guiard, Self Portrait with Two Pupils, 1785
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)

Adelaide Labille-Guilard first trained as a miniaturist and then learned the art of pastel painting from the preeminent Maurice Quentin de la Tour.   Not only was Labille-Guiard an exceptional artist but she was also an astute promoter. Before she was admitted as an academician she exhibited a series of pastel portraits of the most prominent academicians including the director at the Salon de la Correspondence (a commercial exhibition) which must have drawn enough attention for them to be familiar with her name.  She was accepted into the Academie in 1783 along with Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun.  She did not have a royal patron like Vigee-LeBrun nor did she have the privileges accorded a full academician of a salary.  She was training female artists at her studio but she also needed to attract wealthy patrons. 

 Labille-Guiard composed her portraits like large scale history paintings.  In this huge canvas we see an artist working at her easel as her two pupil look-on with admiration.  She engages the viewer by placing them in the position of the subject that she is painting.  Labille-Guiard has positioned herself in the middle of the canvas dressed as an aristocratic lady in a very fashionable, low-cut, satin dress, powdered hair and hat with bows and feathers.  According to Laura Auricchio, her pose and costume would have been instantly recognizable as the images from the published fashion plates that were so popular among the elite audience of fashionable women who were also very desirable patrons.1 She seems to be giving an all-encompassing impression of herself in this self-portrait. On the one hand she is dressed provocatively - her ample bosom is placed at the center of the painting and her little foot peeks under her dress - and on the other, she has two statues behind her one of her father and the other the Vestal Virgin - the former lending a sense of propriety and the latter a sense of  virtue.  She is claiming this is her studio and she is being watched over by her father and the Virgin.

She has shown an incredible mastery with her paints while depicting all the different light effects and textures. The intricacies of her dress are portrayed so realistically that the seams and even the wrinkles are very obvious.  The students in the back are standing in a contrapposto pose which is a concept developed in Classical sculpture and cannot be seen in Jacques-Louis David's figures until after the revolution. The  painting was a huge success.  She was considered to be one step away from a history painter.

Compared to her contemporary Vigee-LeBrun's soft rococo paintings Labille-Guiard's work was always considered more masculine.  Her work was so exceptional that some believed it was actually painted by her lover.  They could not conceive of such mastery in a female.  There were even pamphlets circulating at this time besmirching her name, containing lewd comments that she had to make a complaint about. But being the ever-resourceful woman that she was, she wrote to the wife of the director asking her to intervene on her behalf.  She went on to describe what a stain on her honor would do to her old lonely father.  With a little female intervention, action was taken to arrest and interrogate the printer and seize the pamphlets.2 Labille-Guiard had turned a negative situation into a positive with very influential allies on her side.

Madame Adailade of France, one of the daughters of Louis XIV, wanted to purchase the Self-Portrait with two Pupils but Labille-Guiard would not sell it and instead painted a portrait of the Princess of France in a very similar style as her own.  Mademe Adailade and her sisters became Labille-Guiard's major patrons and since she associated herself with the generation that was previous to the present ruler, she was not targeted by the Revolutionaries. She even painted a portrait of Maximilien Robespierre.

Jacques-Louis David,
The Oath of the Horatii, 1785
(Musee du Louvre)
Unfortunately, over the years, Labille-Guiard was not as widely recognized as her contemporary Vigee-LeBrun who made the cover of a current Survey of Art book while her name doesn't even come up in the index section.  I think this talented artist as well as shrewd businesswoman deserves to be recognized as a painter of the top caliber not just a female portraitist, afterall she risked the wrath of a society who firmly believed the female's place was in the home, behind closed doors, taking care of her children.   Just for the level of success she achieved in 18th century society she deserves to be mentioned with the canons of her generation.; this painting could have been hanging right next to David's monumental Oath of the Horatii. 


1  Auricchio, Lauren. "Self-promotion in Adelaide Labille-Guiard's 1785 Self-Portrait with Two Students." Art Bulletin (2007). 51 
2  Ibid., 48

Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun - Portrait of Marie-Antoinette

Elisabeth Louise Vigee-LeBrun, Portrait of Marie-Antoinette, 1778-1779
(Kunsthistoriches Museum, Vienna) 
Vigee-LeBrun was Marie-Antoinette's favorite portraitist and such a close confidant that the queen aided her entrance to the Academie by having her husband Louis XVI interfere on her behalf .  This event caused whispers that she was intimately involved with the sovereign and in contemporary terms that she basically slept her way to the top. Looking at this portrait of the queen that pronouncement is a little difficult to acknowledge as truth.  Vigee-LeBrun was a true royalist and had to flee France the night of the Revolution are true however.

In this rococo painting of the notorious queen who was blamed to almost single-handedly, bring down the ancien regime Vigee-LeBrun depicts Marie-Antoinette in all her royal glory.  The queen is shown standing in a very elaborate dress of satin and lace with huge paniers holding out the skirts attesting to her noble status.  The red velvet covered table that holds the crown and the bust of her husband Louis XVI seen on top of the column to her right are also some of the elements befitting a queen that are incorporated into the painting.

This is the first portrait Vigee-LeBrun painted of the queen from real life.  Similar to a history painting, it is a huge work involving many components and would have taken several sittings.  Vigee-LeBrun wrote her memoirs explaining how she proceeded with making portraits of royalty, starting with trying to make the sitter very comfortable.    In order to avoid the sitter appearing too tall, she made sure that the head was not placed too high on the canvas.  Another important factor to take into consideration was for the model to be presented in a space where she did not overtake it.

Vigee-LeBrun, The artist's maid, 1778
(Musee Carnivalet, Paris)
Jacques-Louis David,
Queen Marie-Antoinette on the
Way to the Guillotine,
1793
(Musee du Louvre)
Although this is a painting in the rococo style, with an abundance of drapery and flowers and soft brush strokes, critics still identified the brush strokes as a sign of Vigee-LeBrun's identity as a female.   The cross-hatching  technique that was taught at the academy was also considered feminine as opposed to Jacques Louis David's strong contours.  Maybe  identifying all that was of the ancien regime and corrupt as a feminine style and adapting a more stern style in art and calling it more masculine was more consoling to their sensibilities.  It is also interesting to compare Vigee-LeBrun's painting of Marie-Antoinette in 1778 to the drawing of David in 1793. It may even be recognized as a lesson in humility.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Angelica Kauffman - Neoclassicism's Female Hero

Angelica Kauffman, Zeuxis Selecting Models for his Painting of Helen of Troy, 1778
(Brown University Library, Providence, Rhode Island)

"By the ideal, I mean that which one sees only with the imagination, and not with the eyes; thus an ideal in painting depends upon selection of the most beautiful things in nature purified of every imperfection."
- Anton Raphael Mengs

Meng's words ring true of the accepted notion in 18th century that the idealism of Classical art was due to the Greek's search for perfection in nature. Since the Creator's true ideal was dispersed into nature and did not exist as a perfect whole in any one thing, it had to be compiled together by the artist.  It is possible to interpret Angelica Kauffman's painting Zeuxis Selecting Models for his Painting of Helen of Troy as a depiction of this notion.  According to the Roman author Pliny, the ancient Greek painter Zeuxis could not find a woman beautiful enough to portray as Helen of Troy, the archetype of the feminine beauty, so he picked the best features of five virgins to compose the most ideal image of beauty.  In this painting, the male artist is in the process of selecting the most perfect feature of the models; we even see an instrument on the floor by his foot that would be used to measure.  The one feature that sets this interpretation apart is the fifth model to the right of the artist who seems to be standing before the canvas with a brush in her hand.  She has taken the position of the artist/creator and instead of being one of the passive models who are being objectified, she is actively creating art.  Given the gender of the artist, this could be read as Kauffman's commentary on her identity as an artist.  

The Swiss artist Angelica Kauffman was a child prodigy; she was very gifted in art, music and could speak a number of languages.  She was trained by her father, brought to Rome and encouraged to study Classical sculptures and the work of the Renaissance masters.  When she moved to London she befriended Reynolds and impressed her contemporaries so much that she was invited as a founding member to the Royal Academy.  She aspired to be a history painter since this was the top echelon of all the genre's of painting.  Figures were an inherent part of history paintings but female artists had no knowledge of the human anatomy, since they were not allowed to work from a live model.  Kauffman had to rely on her studies from sculptures for her figures.  There were a lot of rumors circulating about Kauffman and she was maligned in the writings of some satirists.  But she still seems to have taken control of her life and career and become a favorite of the aristocracy.   She had moved from the position of objectified female to  the creator/artist. 

The English were not so enthusiastic about history painting as their French counterparts, portraiture was what they demanded.  Along with painting the portraits of "who was who" of her day, Kauffman also painted mythological scenes.  Although the subject of this painting was Neoclassical, the style was still more Rococo.  Instead of the rigid outlines and stoics figures of Neoclassicism, Kauffman used sfumato, her figures blending with the background.  Her diversity as an artist can be better understood when comparing this painting with Cornelia Pointing to Her Children as her Treasures from 1785.

Angelica Kauffman, Cornelia Pointing to her Children as her Treasures, 1785
(Virginia Museum of Fine Arts, Richmond, Virginia)
This painting depicting exemplum virtutis (example of virtue) from Roman history is much closer to Neoclassicism.  Cornelia was a matron known for her virtue, modesty and honor. Here she is being visited by another female who is displaying all her worldly goods, looking askance at Cornelia to see her treasures.  Cornelia points to her sons who have come back from school as her treasures, displaying maternal virtue.  She also holds her daughter's hand but there is a bit of ambiguity when it comes to interpreting this figure.   For one thing, Cornelia does not include her in her treasures causing some to speculate boys were more important than girls.  The little girl seems to be quite taken with the jewelry of the other matron, confirming the stereotypical gender role.   

Stylistically, the Neoclassical elements are present in the figures standing on a shallow, horizontal plane as if on a procession, the wall and the column in the back forming a stark background, the clean outlines  and perspective as well as the subject of female virtue from Roman history.

All the ideals of the scholars and artists of mid 18th century can be seen in Angelica Kauffman's Cornelia.  Her elevated style of painting is in the grand manner as Reynolds was calling for, the morally exemplary subject matter is from ancient Rome, her figures idealized and outlined  as prescribed by Winckelmann and Mengs, thus the artist has seen with her imagination and selected all that is beautiful in nature.  This extraordinary artist who lived in and abided by the norms of a male dominated society that would deny her the right to learn something vital to her profession, still found a way to depict scenes from her unique perspective and is counted as one of the precursors of her time.

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Denis Diderot

Camille Claudel
"First of all move me, surprise me, rend my heart; make me tremble, weep, shudder; outrage me, delight my eyes afterwards, if you can."
                                   - Denis Diderot

I just found this quote by the 18th century French philosopher, writer and art critic of the Enlightenment, Denis Diderot.  He was calling out for a new art from the excessive,depraved style of rococco that was favored by the aristocracy during the reign of Louis XV.

This impassioned statement  resonated within me and I started to think, "Of all the works of art I studied, which stood out and could be the answer to this plea?" After hours of contemplation, I came to the conclusion for me, it was Camille Claudel and Auguste Rodin's sculptures that made my heart tremble, weep and shudder... so much feeling, so much passion, so much pain...

Camille Claudel, The Age of Maturity, 1899
(Musee d'Orsay)




Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...