Showing posts with label Istanbul. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Istanbul. Show all posts

Saturday, September 24, 2016

How preserving cultural heritage sites can help to combat ignorance and fight biased politics

Did you know that one of the oldest sites of human settlement in the Americas, from 15,000 years ago, Cactus Hill, is in Virginia?

The world these days seems to be in a state of constant chaos, with pain and suffering everywhere we turn. Instead of coming together to ease the suffering of those in need, we seem to be more divided than ever.  A big part of the problem is the manipulation of people with half-truths or flat-out lies by the so-called leaders of their own countries. If there is a population of ignorant or even disenfranchised people, those who want to get elected or stay in power are ready with their divisive politics to "divide and conquer." People are fed biased, skewed narratives according to the ideology of those in or near power. While in America, the narrative of America is for Americans can be heard in half the political arenas across the country, half way across the world, in Turkey, politicians appropriating the Ottoman culture in accordance with their vision, are misleading an ignorant populace towards an imported religious ideology that wants to curtail women's rights and impose archaic bans on people's social lives. Although this type of Islam is not the culture of Anatolia, it is being sold as such to the uneducated, the gullible and the innocent believer. Looking at the disheartening political debates taking place all around us, some might ask "Is it possible to combat ignorance and racism?" I argue it is...  by preserving, sharing and respecting cultural heritage.

Abdulmecid Efendi, Last Capliph and 37th Head of the Ottoman Dynasty, Beethoven in the Harem
(Istanbul Resim ve Heykel Muzesi)
(Istanbul Museum of Art and Sculpture) 
In a world full of so many urgent problems, people sometimes have a hard time understanding the emphasis we put on privileging cultural heritage preservation. But the relevance and importance of cultural heritage can be observed all around us, in the daily newspapers, on social media, in what is happening around the world everyday.
I was inspired to write this post after reading numerous articles in the Turkish newspapers about a Symposium being organized at the Parliament, to honor the 34th Ottoman Sultan, Abdulhamid II. Now, some might say, that is a Turkish issue... It has nothing to do with us... Why should we care about this? The specific case is such a great example of guiding the ignorant and the disenfranchised towards a certain ideology, that I think it is relevant to all of us around the world, no matter what religion, nationality or culture we may come from.

Label for Elif Raki produced without anise and referred to as "Plain Raki"
The current speaker of the Turkish Parliament, Ismail Kahraman, during his announcement about the Symposium organized for the occasion of Sultan Abdulhamid II's birthday, is reported as saying:
Unfortunately, history and cultural heritage is not known, especially the youth do not know it, they have been deliberately made to forget, we have a debt to our Sultan Abdulhamid.
To the outsider, this may seem an innocuous statement, but anyone who is familiar with Turkish politics will know the real meaning behind the statement. Sultan Abdulhamid II (r. 1876-1909) is a controversial figure in Turkish politics, being revered as Abdulhamid Han, due to his pan-Islamic ideologies for the Ottoman empire by the conservative Islamists in power today, and remembered for his one-man, autocratic rule, severe paranoia, extensive network of spies who reported and persecuted many innocents by everyone else. This, of course is not the correct way of examining a historical figure but it summarizes the two points of view and strengthens my argument towards the importance of cultural heritage.

Label for "Üzüm Kizi" Raki, produced in Istanbul, 1880s
by the Head Chamberlain of Sultan Abdulhamid II, Ragip Pasha

While the current ruling party, AKP is busy with the apotheosis of Abdulhamid II, they are concurrently trying to smirch the reputation and erase the memory of Ataturk, the founding father of modern, secular Turkey. Although Ataturk's habit of imbibing and entertaining regularly, where issues regarding the new Republic were discussed, are known by all and do not cast a flicker of a shadow on his character or deeds, AKP has been focusing on this as the evidence of the corruption of the foundation of the Republic. They have been calling him a drunk to insult not only Ataturk but everything that he represents. The sweet irony in all this is, that the first raki, beer and champagne production started in the Ottoman empire with the seal and approval of Abdulhamid II...you know the "orthodox" Sultan as opposed to the "drunk" general who had dinner parties every night. It was the Head Chamberlain and one of the ministers of finance in Abdulhamid's court, Ragip Pasha, who opened the first raki production facility in the Ottoman empire. According to his grandson, Abdulhamid was known to prefer rum since it was made from sugar and not specifically prohibited in the Q'uran. Hypocrite or not, this only shows that the Ottoman Sultan was just like any other powerful man of his time... drinking, dancing, watching the performance of European opera companies and even frolicking with cabaret dancers... While one cannot help but be amused by the irony, none of these facts change Abdulhamid's deeds, the good along with the evil; however this post is not about Abdulhamid, but combating ignorance and manipulation of those who deify him, through the preservation of cultural heritage.

Bomonti Brewery, opened 1888-1890, Istanbul

So, what does cultural heritage have to do with this, some might ask. It has everything to do with it.

Those who blindly believe in the rhetoric of populist politicians may disbelieve the facts that are presented to them as newspaper articles or scholarly papers but as they say, seeing is believing. The beauty and significance of material culture is that they stand before us as irrefutable facts. We had such a great opportunity with the Bomonti Brewery in Istanbul, the first modern brewery that opened in 1890 and continued to be in production until 1991. The site was recently renovated as an art, culture and entertainment space. Unfortunately, I was not able to visit it but from the promotion material and the media write ups I have read, it looks to be a carefully planned out space with everything in one complex, from restaurants, exhibition spaces and a bookstore to even a jazz club that utilized the historic texture, merely, as an ornamental backdrop. In light of these latest events, I can't help but ruminate why they could not have preserved it as the very important industrial heritage site that it was.

Aluyulala Hususi Raki Label
The Bomonti Brewery could have been the perfect space to set up a museum on the social life of 19th century Istanbul, highlighting minority narratives, providing information about the neighborhoods and the people who lived in the area. It could have been a space to highlight Industrialization in 19th century Istanbul. It could have been many things but instead of preserving the Industrial Heritage and utilizing it as a space for the dissemination of knowledge about our common past as the descendants of the Ottomans, it was handed over to developers for a venue that will probably be accessible only by the rich, secular, "marginal" (as the President often refers to them) and the few.

Bomonti Beer Gardens
The above example can be adapted to any country with leaders using racist narratives to rally support for their outdated, 19th century political ideologies. We should not judge historical events or figures anachronistically but we should learn from and improve upon them.  By being aware of and understanding the past, we can protect ourselves from fallacy of politicians and engender a better future. That, is why we need to prioritize the preservation of cultural heritage in all of its forms.



Saturday, November 29, 2014

Why Art History - The Treasures of Constantinople


Pope Francis is on a three-day visit to Turkey where he is spending Saturday and Sunday in Istanbul as a guest of Patriarch Bartholomew. I thought this would be a good occasion to recall another Papal visit to Constantinople in 523 by Pope John I. Bishop Ecclesius of Ravenna (mentioned below) was part of his entourage. There is one theory that Anicia Juliana might have commissioned the Church of St. Polyeuktos in accordance with this trip.

The following is an article that was originally posted on Hasan Niyazi's website Three Pipe Problem in August 2013 as a response to the question Hasan posed "Why Art History?"


The remains of the 6th century Church of St. Polyeuktos
It all started with peacocks... those dazzling creatures that represented the eternity of the spirit and had associations with Roman empresses... There once was a church, built by a royal princess who was the noblest in the land, that had a golden dome and was lavishly decorated with the most precious marbles from the empire, colors of green, blue and gold glittering everywhere, with peacock motifs decorating column capitals and niches around the church, it was known to have been inspired from the temple of Solomon. No one knew of its existence till half a century ago when magnificent marble fragments appeared as if by magic in the middle of Istanbul... This, was the Church of St. Polyeuktos in Constantinople, built in the 6th century by Anicia Juliana, a descendant of both Eastern and Western emperors ...

Dome of the Rock, Jerusalem
The first time I had every heard of the Church of St Polyeuktos was when I was doing a book review for this blog on And Diverse are their Hues, exploring the significance of color in Islamic art and culture. In his article "Blue Behind Gold: Inscription of the Dome of the Rock and its Relatives" Dr. Lawrence Nees gave the example of St. Polyeuktos as being one of the fore-bearers for the color scheme and type of decoration used on Dome of the Rock. Dr. Nees painted a radiant picture of a Byzantine church with peacock blue and green used behind gold inscriptions that left me enthralled with this mysterious, magnificent structure and its founder, I had to find out more...


It was during my semester in Istanbul last fall, at a visit to Istanbul Archaeology Museum, I recalled Anicia Juliana and her church once again, upon seeing a capital with peacock motifs. I found the section set aside for the Church of St. Polyeuktos among the Istanbul galleries of the museum, identified by the name of the present day neighborhood where they had been excavated, Saraçhane. There were some beautiful, intricately carved late antique marble works, capitals and columns with a few colored glass still intact, but visualizing the splendor and comprehending the significance of this church required more research.


Saturday, January 25, 2014

Ottoman Princess Mihrimah Sultan

Cameria, Daughter of the Emperor Soliman,
After Cristofano dell' Altissimo, 16th century(?)
(Pera Museum)
The Ottomans have always been a source of fascination, even for citizens of the Turkish Republic, whose knowledge of its more than 600 years of history is still a work in progress. While everyone who has attended school in Turkey would have a rudimentary knowledge of the names and some standard accomplishments of the Ottoman Sultans, the imperial women and their accomplishments are either ignored or mentioned within a negative context. A whole nation, for generations, still does not seem to have been able to get over the fact that Suleyman the Magnificent, legally married Hurrem, forsaking all others, when he was the most powerful man on earth (God's shadow on earth) The concubines in the Harem would rise up to become Haseki Sultan's when they bore a son but were never granted the privilege of becoming the Sultan's wife. While the daughters of the Sultans had a special place within the palace hierarchy and extreme power over their husbands, they are still remembered only in relation to their fathers or husbands - the details of their lives all too often escaping our notice completely. There were few exceptions, one in particular I just had to mention here today...

Mihrimah Sultan, the only daughter of Suleyman the Magnificent and his beloved wife, Hurrem Sultan, was one of the most influential and powerful women in 16th century Ottoman Empire. Almost a contemporary of Queen Elizabeth the Ist of England, born in 1522, Mihrimah died on January 25, 1578, leaving behind a substantial legacy of pious foundations and architectural commissions. She is best known for her two mosque complexes in Uskudar and Edirnekapi districts of Istanbul, both the work of the great architect Sinan. Her letters to her father as well as the one she wrote to King Sigismund II of Poland upon his accession to the throne congratulating him is thought to attest to her superior education and involvement in diplomacy. [1]

Sunday, December 22, 2013

Chora: the Church of the Holy Savior Outside the City Walls


The Anastasis, Church of the St. Savior in Chora, Parekklesion, 1316-21
Chora Museum
The image of the Hagia Sophia always looms commanding and magnificent when one thinks of Istanbul but there is one other Byzantine church that also deserves just as much attention as her bigger, more famous sister, the Church of the St. Savoir in Chora. The magic about the Chora starts with its name, giving us a glimpse into a time and a city that was so far removed from what we know as Istanbul today. The name Chora comes from the Greek word Hora which has been translated as "land", "country" or "in the country," and in this case "outside the wall." Although it is located inside the Land Walls built by Theodosius II in the 5th century, near Adrionople gate, the first church built on this spot was outside of the city walls Constantine established in 324, hence the name. This was due to the ascetic lives lead by monks - at first monasteries would be built away from the city, outside of the city walls, a characteristic that would change in time as private, aristocratic houses in Constantinople would start to be turned into monasteries.

Monday, July 8, 2013

Yedikule Orchards- Destruction of Another Cultural Memory in Istanbul


The Orchards lining the Land Walls of Constantinople

Turkey as a country is probably one of the richest and most diverse when it comes to the cultural memory of its lands and people. The Thracian and Anatolian landscape that we, as Turks inhabit is the birthplace of not only Western civilization but also Christianity as well. Greeks, Romans, Byzantines and finally Ottomans lived and ruled these lands, each leaving behind the traces of their unique culture and history. The historic peninsula in modern day Istanbul is the visual manifestation of the fusion of the two great empires that made it their capital, the Roman and the Ottoman. It is futile to insist a disassociation with the city's Byzantine past just as it is with its Ottoman past... although some still try. As Istanbulites, we are blessed with such a rich cultural memory which unfortunately perishes a little bit more every day.

Bakirkoy, Shore Road

Whenever I fly back to Istanbul my chosen route to get into the city is to take the shore road that runs along the Marmara sea from Bakirkoy all the way past the historic peninsula with its prominent remainders of the Byzantine and Ottoman Empires. It is not only a scenic drive with beautiful vistas all along the way, it is also the same route the Byzantine Emperors had taken,when coming back to their capital from the West, starting in the fourth or fifth century.  It requires quite a vivid imagination today to visualize Bakirkoy as Hebdomon, the seventh milestone from the Roman city. There were seaside palaces and two churches with one built to house the relic head of St John the Baptist.  Like the Campus Martius in Rome, this was where the army camped, exercised and gathered to leave for campaigns. It was also the place where emperors were claimed as emperors by the army in late antiquity.

Francesco Scarella,
Yedikule Fortress (The Fortress of the Seven Towers), ca. 1685


Sunday, June 9, 2013

The Bee in My Bonnet About What is Happening in Turkey

Figen Cebe, Untitled, 2011 , 80 x 100cm
"One tree dies, a nation awakens." Nazim Hikmet
There are defining moments in history that linger in a society's memory that people use as a reference point when they are talking about the past; usually these moments are of events that shocked and devastated a nation like the shooting of JFK or 9/11. I think this past week in contrast will be remembered as one of the most exultant times in history, as the time Turks rebelled...protested... united as a force against their government displaying their solidarity, courage and passion. I am elated to see Turkish people's creativity, ingenuity and unique sense of humor coming into the forefront, reminding us of what we possess within our fold. I must apologize for going off track and writing about something like this on a blog that is supposed to be devoted to art, culture and history but this time I have to make an exception ... since as I already mentioned, these are not ordinary times.

Besiktas, Istanbul where the worst of the police attacks have taken place
Under normal circumstances, I choose to be purposefully ignorant about politics, it is one of those areas that leaves me feeling insignificant and angry but there is nothing ordinary about our circumstances. So, this past week I have become an accidental activist. Considering the photographs from Turkey of the little old ladies walking down the streets of Istanbul with flags in their hands and reports of people passing out food and water, families giving shelter to the protesters, my contribution of posting on Facebook and Twitter incessantly about the developments seems very minimal indeed.

Friday, January 18, 2013

Aelia Eudocia Augusta, whose husband Theodosius II built the Land Walls of Constantinople

Bust Weight of Aelia Eudocia Augusta ?, First Half of 5th century
(Istanbul Archaeology Museum)

There is a small display case in the Istanbul Archaeology Museum that holds some very intriguing objects. They are Empress Bust Weights that were used in the marketplace to weigh everyday commodities. One of the figures thought to be Eudocia, wife of Theodosius II, wears a diadem and a necklace which help to identify her as an Augusta and  a garment that tightly covers her shoulders. While she holds a scroll in one hand and with the other makes the gesture of speech. The gesture of speech normally reserved for Christ, Church figures and imperial officials and sometimes muses, refers to the empresses well-educated status.  The scroll and the wrapped garment also recall the standard gesture of orators and philosophers. With her iconography referring to her learnedness, her imperial diadem claiming her to be an augusta her wide-open eyes suggesting both piety and watchfulness,this fifth century bust weight of Eudocia would have ensured "the fairness of commercial transactions" in the marketplace. 1  

Friday, September 21, 2012

Turkish Embassy Letter 2012

 "I won't trouble you with a relation of our tedious journey, but I must not omit what I saw remarkable at ... one of the most beautiful towns in the Turkish empire..."
                                                           Lady Mary Wortley Montague, 1 April 1717, Adrianople

Being happily settled in Istanbul for the past week, I am now in the possession of many remarkable details in order to start weaving my particular tale of adventures. The rich and exuberant layers of Turkey's history, culture, even people brings to mind the colorful forms of nomadic textiles, enchanting yet ambiguous all at the same time. Ironically this enigma, at times, holds true for Turks and foreigners alike. I embark upon my journey hoping I can be an interpreter of sorts for this country that has fascinated and perplexed people from near and far for so many centuries.

My place of residence for the duration of my stay will be our modest apartment in Sisli, close to the center of town while my daily duties will take me to another part of the city quite far from all the hustle and bustle. The purpose of my extended visit is to study at Koc University for the next four months concentrating on the history of the civilizations and the people that have passed through this unique geography going as far back as prehistoric Anatolia.  Having not been a student in this particular country for the better part of thirty years, this promises to be an unforgettable experience.
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...