Madame Cézanne Sewing, ca. 1877
(Nationalmuseum, Stockholm)
We are in the middle of a record breaking blizzard on the East Coast, and while we are enveloped in the tranquility of mountains of snow, I thought it a perfect opportunity to tackle my own mountain... of photographs taken at numerous museum visits and exhibitions. Since it was Cézanne's birthday this week - he was born on January 19, 1839 - and there was an incredible exhibition at the Metropolitan Museum of Art last year, I decided to post some of my favorites from the exhibit with some notes from the gallery labels that I found interesting. Madame Cézanne, an exhibition of 25 of the 29 portraits the artist painted of his wife and partner Hortense Fiquet, included oils, watercolors and graphite studies, as well as pages from sketch books. Filled with intimate sketches, I loved seeing Cézanne's sketch books and getting an unguarded glimpse into how he observed his world.
Madame Cézanne Leaning on a Table, ca.1873-74
(Private Collection)
Whether he was painting apples and oranges or his beloved Mont Sainte-Victoire, Paul Cézanne is renowned for his obsessive exploration of the many ways of observing and interacting with a particular object or landscape he found interesting. Although I was familiar with Cézanne's portraits, I had never considered portraits of Madame Cézanne along the same lines as his bowls of fruit of Mont Sainte-Victoire, subjects he returned to time and again. After viewing the exhibition and listening to the presentations given at the colloquium for the exhibit, Hortense's position in the artist's life and artistic oeuvre became more clear. Taking in her stoic countenance and plain visage, Hortense Piquet was always disparaged by critics and art historians as being a most unpleasant female that was responsible for holding the artist back. This led me to ponder the meanings we assign to works of art and what it says about our culture as opposed to the artist's intent. Especially with an artist like Cézanne, who constructed his canvases very deliberately brush stroke by brush stroke, it seems so misleading to think of Hortense's portraits as mere likenesses revealing her inner persona. As the Met website states "the portraits attest to the constancy of a relationship that was critical to the artist's practice and development."
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1886-87
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)
Cézanne's carefully constructed canvases are an infinite source of fascination for me, as I roam their surfaces, following his contours as they outline forms, becoming more pronounced, dissolving into the background or just stopping in midair. The many layers of color used to build up his paintings create an oscillating effect constantly shifting and generating movement. I find Cézanne's paintings intriguing not only for the full experience of space they convey, including different points of view, angles as well as shifts in light and shade but also for what he tried to achieve. According to the late Philipe Conisbe, who used to be the senior curator of European Art at the National Gallery in Washington:
Maybe his greatest goal was to try to put into permanent artistic form, his feeling of engagement with the world. His sense of being in the world... his existential experience as a man and an artist.
So, here is a selection from Madame Cézanne, an extraordinary exhibition for an extraordinary subject ...
Madame Cézanne in a Red Armchair, ca. 1877
(Museum of Fine Arts, Boston)
When poet Rainer Maria Rilke discovered this portrait at the 1907 Salon d'Automne, he was overcome with emotion. Writing to his wife, he described the intensity of the color relationships even in his sleep, "color coming into its own in response to another, asserting itself, recollecting itself... in this hither and back of mutual and manifold influence, the interior of the picture vibrates, rises and falls back into itself, and does not have a single unmoving part."
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1890-92
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1877
(Private Collection)
Cézanne emphasizes the interiority of his model; she is positioned close to the picture plane, with head titled forward and eyes lowered. It may be the most abstract of all the portraits. The hair, with its wide central part, is highly simplified and the stripes on the dress emphatically refuse to model the torso. These vertical lines echo across the canvas.
Portrait of Madame Cézanne in a Striped Dress, ca. 1883-85
(Yokohama Museum of Art)
This portrait, one of the few portraits of Hortense shown in Cézanne's famed 1895 exhibition at Ambroise Vollard's gallery in Paris was also came to the Armory Show in New York in 1913.
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1885-87
(Philadelphia Museum of Art)
There has been much speculation about the curtain-like abstraction of flowers and leaves at the top of this painting. Technical investigation reveals that Cézanne reused this canvas and that these forms were appropriated from an earlier composition, a floral still life that was in turn based on the contours of an abandoned figure.
Portrait of Madame Cézanne in the Conservatory, 1891
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)
The varying degrees of finish in this portrait allow us to track its evolution from the Conté crayon or graphite underdrawing to the application of colored washes and body color, which are accumulated to balanced perfection in the head.
Madame Cézanne in Blue, 1888-90
(Museum of Fine Arts, Houston)
Each portrait of Hortense has its own color scheme. Cézanne established a subdued version of his palette in the underpaint, and then went on to articulate brighter hues across the canvas Color correspondences, sometimes quite subtle, eventually tie the structure together. Working with a narrow palatte in this example, the artist laid passages of ochre in the sideboard and wallpaper, and gray-blue in the dress and paneled door. He then syncopated these colors throughout the canvas in small calculated touches.
Portrait of Madame Cézanne ca. 1885
(Private Collection, on loan to Staatliche Museen zu Berlin)
Cézanne's brushwork and paint density thins in the 1880s. This shift is nowhere more apparent than in this ravishing bust-length portrait of Hortense, which itself is very similar in structure and curlicues choreograph the pattern while individual strokes of paint fill in the anatomy. Soft pinks and flesh tones describe a tender face, gazing head on, as if in dialogue with the artist.
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1885-87(Musée d'Orsay, Paris)
The application of paint in this work has more in common with watercolor technique than with oil. For most of the portraits in oil, beyond the underpaint, Cézanne mixed his colors with white, which added opacity. Here, by contrast, the artist built up color very thinly with glazes and semiglazes.
Portrait photography by Albert Eugene Gallatin
of Henri Matisse with this painting, in his Nice
apartment, 1932
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1885-88
(Musée d'Orsay, Paris)
Sketch of a Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1883
(Richard and Mary L. Gray and the Gray Collections Trust)
Woman Nursing Her Child, 1872
Young Woman with Loosened Hair, ca. 1873-74
These two tender images of the young Hortense are the earliest traceable painted portraits of her. As a rare snapshot of family life, the portrait on the right is a poignant artifact of a lifelong partnership, here in its nascency.
PAUL CÉZANNE: DRAWINGS AND WATERCOLORS FROM THE METROPOLITAN COLLECTION
Still Life with a Watermelon and Pomegranates, ca. 1900-1906
Page Studies, Including Madame Cézanne Sewing, 1877-80
Cézanne employed his sketchbooks for visual notations of all kinds, often using the same sheet over several years. Here, the near horizontal Hortense, bearing a somewhat dismayed expression, shares the leaf with a study of Victor Chocquet, a drawing of a table end, and a sketch of a woman sewing, laid out in framing lines. It is very possible that Cézanne used Conté crayon rather than graphite to achieve the jet-black definition of form.
Portrait of Madame Cézanne, ca. 1890
This unfinished sketch offers clues to Cézanne's methodology as a watercolorist. He outlined his composition in pencil and then laid in form using blue watercolor both for the figure and background.
Sketch of Madame Cézanne
(Private Collections)
Over the course of is lifetime, Cézanne returned repeatedly to his earlier sketchboooks, filling in empty spaces with more drawings. This practice is evident from the different pencil tones on the pages and the often odd assemblage of images. This charming study of Hortense (right), with her head tilted, is evocative of many of the artist's oils. There is a tenderness to her expression and to the later inscription above her, probably in the hand of young Paul.
Paul Gauguin, Self-Portrait (with portrait of Emile Bernard)
dedicated to Van Gogh, (Les Miserables) 1888
(Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam)
Vincent Van Gogh, Self-Portrait dedicated to Gauguin, 1888
(Fogg Art Museum, Harvard University)
Emile Bernard, Self-Portrait with Portrait of Gauguin,1888
(Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam)
Van Gogh was trying to get Gauguin to come down to Arles in order to establish his vision of an artist's colony there, he even wrote to Gauguin "...think of yourself as the head of this studio." Van Gogh's brother, Theo was going to pay for Gauguin to come down to visit him. The dialog between the two artists, at one point culminated in an exchange of self-portraits. He desperately wanted this exchange of artistic ideas. As a matter of fact, there is a third self-portrait in this exchange that Emile Bernard sent to Van Gogh with a portrait of Gauguin hanging on the wall behind him. Van Gogh ultimately wanted to get Emile Bernard and all their artist friends to come down to Arles as well but he decided to start by luring Gauguin first.
Gauguin was the first one to send his portrait to Van Gogh. In his Self-Portrait dedicated to Van Gogh, Gauguin also included on the back wall a portrait of his artist friend Emile Bernard whom he was working near in Normandy at that time. In a way it was a commentary on his situation of already being established in an artist's colony and his expression of looking askance as if to say "can you do this?" added to the overall effect of being in a better situation.
The wallpaper behind Gauguin with the white flowers is the same bright yellow as Van Gogh's Sunflowers. Van Gogh in turn responds with color, to Bernard's portrait on the wall behind Gauguin. It is an incredibly hard to reproduce color, Veronese green, which is not available today because of its arsenic containing toxic quality. With the colors, he uses, Van Gogh represents his meditative side.
Instead of a centered composition of the portrait format, Gauguin puts himself off center and breaks away from tradition. He has put an inscription at the bottom of his painting 'Les Miserables' - with this he is referencing Jean Valjean, the main character who is an ex-convict from Victor Hugo's Les Miserables. Gauguin liked the idea of himself as the passionate man who doesn't quite fit into bourgeois society. He has also depicted half his face in dark while the other half is in light, which pronounces his good and evil sides. Van Gogh must have picked up on these allusions since he reports to his brother that Gauguin seems desperate and not at all serene. As a response to this, Van Gogh paints himself as a Bonze, a Japanese Buddhist monk, he even goes as far as to slant his eyes as well as a shaved head in the portrait. He paints an aura around his head to reinforce the element of spirituality. He says that he wants to bring Gauguin back to serenity. He also mentions to his brother that he painted himself not only as himself but as an Impressionist, someone who lives to paint.
In their respective self-portraits, while Gauguin is representing himself as a renegade, Van Gogh wants to represent himself as a serious, meditative monk. The composition, the colors, and the symbols all point out the message each one wants to convey to the other. Van Gogh writes that when he put them side by side, he is happy with the outcome, that his portrait can hold its own...
The letter for Vincent van Gogh to his brother Theo van Gogh, from Arles, dated October 7 1888 is below; in it one can find Van Gogh's inner thoughts and feelings... Also there is a very interesting video at the bottom of the page from http://smarthistory.org.
My dear Theo,
Many thanks for your letter. How glad I am for Gauguin; I shall not try to find words to tell you - let's be of good heart.
The Gauguin is of course remarkable, but I very much like Bernard's picture. It is just the inner vision of a painter, a few abrupt tones, a few dark lines, but it has the distinction of a real, real Manet.
The Gauguin is more studied, carried further. That, along with what he says in his letter, gave me absolutely the impression of its representing a prisoner. Not a shadow of gaiety. Absolutely nothing of the flesh, but one can confidently put that down to his determination to make a melancholy effect, the flesh in the shadows has gone a dismal blue.
So now at last I have a chance to compare my painting with what the comrades are doing.My portrait, which I am sending to Gauguin in exchange, holds its own, I am sure of that. I have written to Gauguin in reply to his letter that if I might be allowed to stress my own personality in a portrait, I had done so in trying to convey in my portrait not only myself but an impressionist in general, had conceived it as the portrait of a bonze, a simple worshiper of the eternal Buddha.
And when I put Gauguin's conception and my own side by side, mine is as grave, but less despairing. What Gauguin's portrait says to me before all things is that he must not go on like this, he must become again the richer Gauguin of the “Negresses.”
I am very glad to have these two portraits, for they finally represent the comrades at this stage; they will not remain like that, they will come back to a more serene life.
And I see clearly that the duty laid upon me is to do everything I can to lessen our poverty.
No good comes the way in this painter's job. I feel that he is more Millet than I, but I am more Diaz then he, and like Diaz I am going to try to please the public, so that a few pennies may come into our community. I have spent more than they, but I do not care a bit now that I see their painting—they have worked in too much poverty to succeed.
Mind you, I have better and more saleable stuff than what I have sent you, and I feel that I can go on doing it. I have confidence in it at last. I know that it will do some people's hearts good to find poetic subjects again, “The Starry Sky,”“The Vines in Leaf,”“The Furrows,”the “Poet's Garden.”
Bernard has again sent me a collection of ten drawings with a daring poem - the whole is called At the Brothel.
You will soon see these things, but I shall send you the portraits when I have had them to look at for some time.
I hope you will write soon, I am very hard up because of the stretchers and frames that I ordered.
What you told me of Freret gave me pleasure, but I venture to think that I shall do things which will please him better, and you too.
Yesterday I painted a sunset.
Gauguin looks ill and tormented in his portrait!! You wait, that will not last, and it will be very interesting to compare this portrait with the one he will do of himself in six months' time.
Someday you will also see my self-portrait, which I am sending to Gauguin, because he will keep it, I hope.
The head is modeled in light colours painted in a thick impasto against the light background with hardly any shadows. Only I have made the eyes slightly slanting like the Japanese.
Write me soon and the best of luck. How happy old Gauguin will be.
A good handshake, and thank Freret for the pleasure he has given me. Good-by for now.
This was Georges Seurat's last painting that he exhibited at the Salon des Independants in 1891 in its unfinished state. He died a couple of days after hanging the painting. This painting contains all the elements Seurat was interested in and experimenting with, but we don't know how much further or in which direction he might have gone from here since he died so young, leaving behind his own version of optical blending of color called pointillism.
Jules Cheret, Hippodrome de la PorteMaillot,
Paris Courses, 1890
Le Cirque is a very good example of how Seurat incorporated popular imagery and interpreted the condition of modern society into his work. He could have looked to one of Jules Cheret's posters advertising the Paris Courses at the Hippodrome de la Porte Maillot, or a Ball at the Moulin Rouge, for this particular painting; some of the figures and colors are almost exact replicas. Seurat was known to have admired how Gustave Courbet used popular culture as a source for fine art. This was a time when posters were starting to be used for the advertisement of popular entertainments and Cheret's posters would have been all over Paris. What Seurat accomplished by breaking down barriers was cause for criticizim for bringing in too much popular culture to his work.
Theatrical subject matters like the circus were also a favorite with Degas, who also might have had an influence on Seurat's selection of this particular motif.
This painting with all its upward moving diagonals and warm colors, all of which would have suggested a happy and uplifting experience, in actuality could have been a critique of spectatorship. The audience seems to be unresponsive to the spectacle that was taking place in front of their eyes. This was a time when people of all classes were looking to find entertainments in a city like Paris that in itself had become a spectacle as T. J. Clark called it in his book, The Painting of Modern Life.
Seurat applied Henry Chevreul's theory of the balancing contrasting colors to create harmony by painting a blue frame to the predominantly yellow color of this picture.
Observing how Seurat has flattened the picture plane even more than his previous works and the different points of perspective offered within the painting and the juxtaposition of the different concerns throughout the history of art being incorporated in his own unique vision makes me wonder what was next if he had lived a longer life.
Charles Henry, a French biologist and philosopher wrote a book Introduction to a Scientific Aesthetics that theorized psychological and physiological implications of color and line. According Henry's theory, lines moving in an upward direction were suggestive of happiness, while lines moving downwards suggested sadness and warm color moving from blue-green to red (including green, yellow and orange) were pleasing and uplifting while cool colors moving from red to blue-green (including blue, purple) resulted in feelings of sadness.
Georges Seurat was familiar with Henry's theories and believed that art was harmony which was an analogy of contrary and similar elements of tone, color and line. When considered in this light, Le Chahut, can be regarded as a painting about the psychological effects of color and line. The canvas is made up of predominantly warm colors, orangy reds and some yellow(that changed in the years after it was painted.) All the lines in the painting are moving upwards causing an uplifting mood. Except for the one linear line in the left side of the canvas everything is at diagonals. The girls' and men's legs, their facial features, men's mustaches even the ribbons on their shoes and shoulders seems to be have taken flight upwards. The Base player in the front of the picture plane with his back turned, connects the painting with its frame, he forms a huge triangle that grounds the composition. There is also an orchestra chef and an audience that goes around the stage who are following the show. The viewer is behind the orchestra, similar to some of Degas' ballet paintings. The other prominent figure in the painting is the man with a pug-nose who is sitting on the right side of the painting. His features recall a satyr's, making the viewer aware of the an underlying seedy, sexualized behavior taking place. As a matter of fact, it does look like he is looking up the skirts of the dancer in front of him. Satyr's were supposed to have an insatiable appetite for sex.
This is the scene of a tacky entertainment that was in one of the establishments that was being frequented by the newly emerging lower and middle classes. It is a chorus line of men and women doing the high kick, as opposed to the opera or the ballet. It also is a good example of the influence of popular culture on Seurat's work recalling Jules Cheret's posters that were all over Paris at the time. In Le Chahut, Seurat has taken all the elements that interested him from the contemporary culture and redefined it all in his own terms of geometry, color and harmony.
Georges Seurat, Les Poseuses,1886-1888
(Barnes Foundation, Merion, Pennsylvania)
Here Seurat depicts three models (they are probably the same woman in different poses) in the process of getting undressed in order pose for the artist, in his studio. They stand in front of his painting, A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, with their paraphernalia strewn around them, making us aware of their state of undress and their status as working women. The three women bring to mind the Three Graces from Greek mythology, viewed from front, side and back but Seurat dispels any notion of a timeless mythological narrative here with not only the contemporaneousness of the clothing that the models have taken off but also through the very commonplace practice of models taking off their costumes to pose for the artist.
Seurat's work encompasses a lot of tension, between idealized art and modern science, as well as popular culture and elite, high art. Here, the artist's interest in the artistic ideals of the past, is evident thorough how he has incorporated the figures in this painting from known references in traditional art; something his contemporary audience would have immediately recognized.
Ingres, The Bather of Valpincon, 1808
Les Poseuses has been interpreted as a reworking of the representation of the female nude in Western art. We can trace the sources of his inspiration right here.
The model on the left is taken from Ingres' The Bather of Valpincon, recalling the tradition of the female nude in French art. Seurat has the model seated partially covered with a sheet around her buttocks, facing away from the viewer completely while the Ingres is almost a 3/4 view of a totally nude figure.
Venus Pudica, Greek 1st C. BC
The woman standing in the middle is a reference to Venus Pudica ( the modest Venus) a term used for the classical female nude in traditional Western art that is covering her genitalia. One of the most famous works of the ancient Greek sculptor, Praxiteles of Athens, form 4th century B.C. was the Aphrodite of Cnidus which is now lost but the best- known type of this Venus is a copy signed by Menophantos from 1st century BC. This gesture has been used by artists throughout the history of western art including Sandro Botticelli in The Birth of Venus. Seurat recalls this pose but has taken off the drapery and the elongated grace out of the traditional figure.
Spinario, Boy with Thorn in His Foot,
Roman marble copy c.25-50
The young woman with the green stockings is taken from Spinario, Boy with Thorn, a statue which was one of the few Roman statues that was not lost; it was a favorite with artists from different generations to reference. Here Seurat has taken the boy and made him a woman and instead of taking a thorn out of his foot, she is putting stockings on her feet.
Eadweard Muybridge
Seurat was also very interested in the technological advancements of his time. In the late 1870's photographer Eadweard Muybridge was working on capturing figures in motion in a series of photographs. The three different poses recalling Muybridge's works about the human body in motion, could be attributed to Seurat's interest in photography.
The stiff formality of La Grande Jatte, has been softened in Les Poseuses making the figures appear more natural but the tension that is often seen in Seurat's work is present between what is the disarrayed scene before and inside the monumental masterpiece. The whole painting is united by the use of color; the artist's studio that is seen in front of the frame of La Grand Jatte contains the exact same shades of colors that are inside the painting's frame, creating an ambiguous image blurring the difference between the artwork and reality of the studio.
Everything about Les Poseuses, seems to be reinforcing the idea of 'art as artifice.' By using classical idealized elements of traditional art, Seurat has constructed a contemporary, matter-of-fact scene that is taking place in his studio. We can further delve into his motives by looking at the dictionary definition for the word 'Poseuse' which is a person who habitually pretends to be something he is not. This is yet another thought provoking painting by Seurat that is open to many interpretations.
George Seurat, A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, 1884-1886
(Art Institute of Chicago)
Is this monumental painting by Georges Seurat a commentary on artifice, about alienation of modern life or is it actually a utopian vision?
There are clues to support both arguments, the calm and peacefulness that permeates the whole canvas, and the harmony of people from different classes enjoying a sunny day on the Island of Grand Jatte could be considered a utopian ideal of how society should be, representing a peaceful time in France without any war or revolutions. Everything in the painting is calm and sedate almost as if Seurat has captured and immortalized the one perfect moment.
Pierre Puvis de Chavannes, The Sacred Grove, 1884
(Art Institute of Chicago)
Art historian Linda Nochlin puts forth another idea though - that this is actually a criticism of modern society, an anti-utopian image. Since everyhting should be analyzed in the right context, she starts her argument by first explaining what was considered Utopian at the time this painting was painted. The Sacred Grove by Pierre Puvis de Chavannes, was exhibited in the Salon of 1884, the year Seurat started working on A Sunday on La Grande Jatte and according to Lochlin Seurat's painting might never have come into existence or at least not in this way if it was not for his older contemporary's work. If the Impressionists were the painters of modern life, depicting everyday events, people dressed in contemporary fashions going about in places that were in vogue at the time, then Puvis and his timeless muses in classical settings without any specificity was the antithesis of this type of painting. Seurat seems to be enforcing the contemporaneousness and exactitude of his work even in his title - A Sunday on La Grande Jatte. But Seurat's work was also in contrast to the Impressionist's works like Renoir, who had created his own utopian vision in Dance at the Moulin de la Galette. While Renoir's typical hazy brushwork, with fusing colors in this idyllic scene of merriment amongst the young working class women and middle class artists made the modern urban scene seem very natural, Seurat's stoic figures depicted in his highly technical brushwork made it seem strange.
Pierre-August Renoir, Dance at the Moulin de la Galette,1876
(Musee d'Orsay)
According to Nochlin, Seurat's painting can be interpreted as a criticism of the banality and monotonousness of modern life with cookie-cutter figures standing around in what she calls his sardonic pageant of frozen recreation.1
Seurat achieved this almost mechanical impression due to his repetitive technique of divisionism, applying small dot-like strokes of similar size and shape on top of a uniform color. The separate colors were supposed to be mixed by the viewers eye. He used different patterns for different parts of the painting that was so elaborately done that at an ideal distance it was supposed to look like the real thing. Georges Seurat was familiar with Michel Eugene Chevreul's book, On the Law of Simultaneous Contrast of Color, which confirmed that harmony can be achieved by juxtaposing similar intensities of the same color or by balancing contrasting colors. Chevreul proposed that combinations of complementary colors appear pleasing to the eye. This is especially apparent in the frame of the painting that Seurat added later on to form a transitional zone to make the picture pop. He also used what is known as the Chevreul illusion, when you put a slightly darker tone next to a slightly lighter tone the eye is tricked to see the outer edge darker. Seurat darkened the edges where they met the light areas to achieve a sharper contrast between the figure and the ground.
Seurat made 27 preliminary sketches for this painting. The landscape was en plein air study but for the figures he made drawings in his studio. The final sketch for the Grande Jatte was done in balaye, a criss-cross brush stroke. When looking at his separate sketches in becomes more apparent how he built up the final image for his painting.
Georges Seurat, Study for A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, (Metropolitan Museum of Art)
The technique and the structure of A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, seem to reinforce the alienating, banal and dehumanizing aspects of modern life. As Linda Nochlin points out, "Seurat, with the dot, resolutely and consciously removed himself as a unique being projected by a personal handwriting."2 Georges Seurat, by his mechanical, disembodied construction of his painting undermined the Western tradition of representation and in the process angered a big part of the art community. Especially Monet and Renoir hated this loss the sense of spontaneity and didn't show their work in the last Impressionist exhibit of 1886. But a movement beyond Impressionism for avant-garde painting had already started to evolve and as a response to Seurat, Monet painted his version of monumental figures in landscape in strictly impressionist terms.
1 Linda Nochlin, Seurat's Grande Jatte: An Anti-Utopian Allegory, 255-258 2 Ibid., 255