Showing posts with label Pointillism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pointillism. Show all posts

Monday, April 25, 2011

Impressionist's Response to Seurat's Pointillism

Georges Seurat began his career as an impressionist concerned with the effects of light but later went on to reform it and approach Impressionism in a whole new perspective, as a result of which being referred to as a Neo-Impressionist.  He incorporated scientific theories into his art and surpassed the momentariness of his contemporaries and built canvases that would recall the treasures of the past from the art of the  Egyptians to the friezes of the Parthenon.  Some people loved his work while a lot of the Impressionists despised it.  His stilted, frozen figures were severely criticized by Monet who went on to paint a series of paintings as a response to Seurat to get beyond Impressionism.

Camille Pissaro, Apple Picking, 1886
(Ohara Museum of Art, Kurashiki, Okayama, Japan)




Pissaro, on the other hand embraced Seurat's Pointillism and announced that Impressionism had become rancid, too romantic, stale, old and dried up.  He incorporated Seurat's technique into classical Pissaro subject matter in Apple Picking from 1886.









Camille Pissaro, The Boulevard Montmarte on  a Winter Morning, 1897
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)



But by 1897, after working in this manner for a couple of years, he was back to the Impressionistic style because he realized Seurat's style was too static.  Pissaro thought that it was not possible to capture the momentariness, the colors or the effects of Impressionism with Pointillism.

Monet and Renoir were especially upset with Seurat's work.  Claude Monet who had not done much of figure painting since his earlier days, suddenly did monumental figures in landscapes.  He found Seurat's figures too static so he painted figures full of dynamism with everything in motion as a response to A Sunday on La Grande Jatte.  He achieved this by color, using oranges, yellows and blues, plus with his vigorous brush work.  The clouds are moving, the grass is swaying, the figure's dress and scarf is fluttering in the wind.


Claude Monet, Study of a Figure Outside:  Woman with a Parasol Turned to the Left and Turned to the Right, 1886


                 These paintings are Monet's critique of Seurat's figures in A Sunday at Le Grand Jatte.

Around this time Monet had decided to broaden his and Impressionism's horizons outside of just Paris and its environs.  He traveled out to different regions of France and painted numerous canvases on subjects of his interest - weather and light effects, clouds, crashing waves - the drama of nature. As he traveled throughout the country to Etrerat, Grand-Camp, Belle Ille, and Antibes, and documented the French countryside, Monet's desire to proclaim his and Impressionism's association with the French nation as a whole, came into realization.

During his travels Monet revisited destinations that were main tourist attractions and also were painted by Georges Seurat in his pointillist technique, and reworked these subjects in pure Impressionist style.


Claude Monet, Cliff Walk at Pourville, 1882
(Art Institute of Chicago)




Georges Seurat, La Bec du Hoc, Grancamp, 1885
(Tate Gallery, London)

While in Monet's Cliff Walk at Pourville, even the grass is moving and there is no clear edge, in Seurat's Le Bec du Hoc, the edges are clearly defined and the birds in the air, the only living thing on the canvas look still.
Claude Monet, Rocks at Belle Isle, 1886
(Pushkin Museum of Fine Arts, Moscow)

When Monet was painting these rocks in a spot that is a little bit father down the coast from where Seurat made his painting in Grancamp,  Monet must have been thinking of him.  The deep blue and violet tones of the water shows the dynamism of the sea and how dangerous the coast is. Monet uses the same tones he uses in the water, in the rock formations along with yellow and orange to emphasize the light effects. Interestingly enough, Seurat also uses yellow and oranges for his light effects but without any of Monet's dynamism.


Monet talked about the difficulties he was having during his stay in Belle Isle, in his letters to Alice Hoschede and his friends.   The canvases he produced in Belle Isle had no trace of humanity, only earth, sky and sea.  He wrote about the crashing waves and the mist and how difficult it was to paint in these conditions, creating the myth of Monet as the artist who was deeply and personally involved with nature.  Although, Monet actually would finish his paintings in his studio.  By concentrating on the weather and light conditions, in specific sites, Monet proved the lengths he could go to in Impressionism and the exacting depiction of natural phenomenon.
His Belle Ille paintings were the first of his series paintings where he used a standard format for all the canvases and concentrated on a limited motif, and exhibited several together as a group.  These were the predecessor of his famous Grain Stacks series.



















Sunday, April 17, 2011

Georges Seurat - Pointillism - A Sunday on La Grande Jatte


Georges Seurat, A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, 1884
(The Art Institute of Chicago)
Georges Seurat was a key post-impressionist painter who changed the course of modern art by his use of latest scientific theories on color and light and it's relationship to optical theories.  His monumental masterpiece A Sunday on La Grande Jatte, not only shook the foundations of the art world by its use of the divisionist technique of applying small points of unmodulated color to be mixed in the viewer's eye instead of the artist's palette but also the obvious mixing of people from different social classes out for a leisurely Sunday, by the Seine, each enjoying nature in their own way.

Seurat, who exhibited this painting in the last Impressionist exhibit in 1886 was only 26 years old at the time.  He came from a wealthy family who supported him throughout his life that ended at age 31.  Georges Seurat started his artistic career with a very classical training at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts but quit after a year and half.  Following a mandatory year of military service, he continued working on black and white drawings and small scale paintings.  Only four years after leaving art school, he started the project that would take two years to complete and end up to be this monumental canvas.

Georges Seurat was very interested in art from antiquity, in Greek and Roman sculptures. In his works there is a tension between the contemporary, popular culture and references to elite high art of Egyptian, Greek and Romans.  He also looked to the work of early 19th century artists like Gustave Courbet, Francois Millet as well as Impressionists like Camille Pissaro.
Jean-Francois Millet, The Gleaners, 1857
(Musee d'Orsay)
Georges Seurat, Farm Women at Work,
1882-1883
(Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, NY)
In his early work, Seurat was interested in the 19th century obsession of  peasant in the field imagery.  In the Farm Women at Work, it is easy to see him looking to Millet.  He has taken the two figures from The Gleaners and reversed their directions.  The yellow sunlight reflecting off of the green grass demonstrates his desire to represent light, like Monet.  The one fundamental difference in Seurat's work is the way he put down the reflected lights next to the local color of green in the grass by what is called balaye, a criss-cross brush stroke. In order to create a more vivid and luminous effect, he used juxtaposition of tones of similar colors next to each other for the viewer's eye to blend them on the canvas.

Seurat's interest in luminosity, the linear design element and the extremely important edges of objects can all be found in his black and white drawings in conte crayon on Michallet paper.  These drawings were not preliminary sketches but drawings done as finished works.  He would fill in his subject with conte crayon and then take out the light areas by erasing them, darkening the edges so the lighter area would separate the figure from the background.  The texture of the paper would not allow the crayon to absolutely soak into the paper, allowing the light of the background to shine through, enabling to create lightness.

Georges Seurat, Aman-Jean, 1882-1883
                         
Georges Seurat, The White Coat (The Woman with
 White Umbrella)
1883

Georges Seurat, Eden Concert, 1886-1887
In these drawings, Seurat achieved an aura-like effect around his figures which can be seen very clearly around the umbrella in The White Coat.  To make his subjects pop out, he began to darken the edges like the man's nose in Aman-Jean and the woman's skirts in The White Coat, this helped to separate the figure from the background.  He used the same technique in his paintings as well and the darkened edges caused not only the figures to pop from the background but also helped to reinforce each figure's own space. Even though there is an ambiguity surrounding the exact message Seurat was trying to convey in his art as to whether it was a critique or praise for the modern way of life, his technique seem to work to great effect in all his works.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...