Showing posts with label Jean-Baptiste Greuze. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jean-Baptiste Greuze. Show all posts

Sunday, October 9, 2011

Jean-Baptiste Greuze - Septimius Severus and Caracalla

Jean-Baptiste Greuze, Septimius Severus and Caracalla, 1769
(Musee du Louvre, Paris)

Jean-Baptiste Greuze came from Tournus, the son of a roof master who tried to thwart his son's artistic tendencies at an early age.  He received his early training in Lyons, then traveled onto Paris and enrolled at the Academie to continue his studies.   He is noted as having made a great fuss when he was given an unsatisfactory seat in life class.  Greuze then traveled onto Italy in the company of abbe Gaugenot which according to art historian Anita Brookner was wasted on him since he was too much under the influence of Flemish and Dutch models.1  

When Greuze first entered the Academie, he wanted to be a Genre painter, showing domestic scenes with popular connotations which was in the middle of the hierarchy of acceptable styles.  The hierarchy of Genres were as follows:  History painting; Portrait painting; Genre painting; Landscape; Still Life.  Although he wasn't an fully accepted academician yet, Greuze was sending his paintings to the Salon, the official exhibition of the Academie that informed the public of the quality of works produced by the academicians. The artists who were permitted into the Academie were supposed to submit a reception piece that was judged and accepted into the different levels of the academy.  Greuze who had been protected by influential people had not submitted his reception piece till 1769. 

The artist usually would have a sponsor to help, critique and guide him on his reception piece but Greuze arrogantly decided to do it by himself without any assistance artistically or financially.  Since he was financing the painting himself, it ended up being smaller than the usual size of the pieces admitted to the jury.  In his attempt to impress the jury Greuze picked an obscure story from antiquity that was based on speech and had no decipherable meaning without the words.  The story Greuze was trying to depict was the Roman emperor Septimius Severus reproaching his son Caracalla who had tried to kill him and telling him that all he would have to do if wanted to accomplish this would be to tell his guards.  As odd as the story was Greuze's unacceptable depiction of the protagonists provided the academicians with further ammunition to completely destroy it.  The limp arm of the Emperor pointing at his son was so out of character for a man in his position as well as Caracalla's strange expression of a boy who is being scolded that even though Greuze had done his studies of the anatomy in the nude as was the correct way for the academy, it still ended up being a failure.  He was still admitted into the academy but at the lower level of genre painter which he took as the biggest insult.  When he showed this painting at the Salon it was not appreciated by anyone there either.  Taking offense, Greuze decided not to exhibit at the Salon anymore and eventually died unnoticed and in poverty.  

1  Brookner, Anita. "Jean-Baptiste Greuze-I" The Burlington Magazine Publications Ltd. Vol 98, No 638, May 1956 


Jean-Baptiste Greuze - The Village Bride

Jean-Baptiste Greuze, The Village Bride, 1761
(Musee du Louvre)
Jean-Baptiste Greuze's (1725-1805) moralizing and sentimental paintings, appealed to the bourgeois of mid 18th century Paris who resented the aristocracy's moral decadence and impervious attitude towards the rest of the country and Greuze himself was deduced to be the artist to end the debasement of French Art.  Greuze especially received high praise from the critic Diderot because he saw a connection between Greuze's paintings and his own plays on the drame bourgeois (bourgeois drama based on the life and problems of the middle-classes.)  The entwined hands of the engaged couple in The Village Bride, especially appealed to the Salon-goers since it represented the sentiments of the middle classes of a marriage based on love instead of convenience, money or titles like that of the upper classes.

This narrative painting reminiscent of Dutch genre paintings, depicts the moment of the exchange of the dowry from the father into the bridegroom's hand that is being recorded by the public notary and being witnessed by the whole family.  The most important focal point is in the middle with the hands exchanging the money. The father is the only one speaking while the rest of the family are rendered displaying different emotions with gestures as part of little vignettes throughout the painting.   The contemporary viewer would be able to make a direct connection with the unfolding drama.

Greuze had taken classes at the Academy before going to Italy with his patron for two years. He submitted The Village Bride, to the Salon of 1771 on his return from Rome.  Although the style and subject matter are quite the opposite of what was mostly being shown at the Salon, Greuze applied the concepts he had learned at the Academy to this painting.  

All the elements of the Village Bride,demonstrate the genuine, loving environment of a family with humble means.  A stark but clean and orderly household is set before us in a shallow, stage-like setting.  The bread stocked up on the shelf at the top of the painting, alludes to the father's success at providing for his family.  Using the pyramidal shape that was taught at the Academy, the painting is divided into two distinct spaces - the male side on the right and the female side on the left of the canvas.  There is a little boy placed along with the females who may be too young to belong on the male sphere and an ambigous female standing behind the father who could be an older sister not sharing the same sentiment as the rest of the females in the family or a servant who has come in from the outside.  The female sphere is emphasized with the curving line moving through connecting the figures all the way up to the middle of the painting while the male sphere is accentuated with straight lines and geometric elements that can be picked up on the documents, the tricorne hat of the notary as well as the chairs they are sitting on . The separation is also accomplished with the placement of the females as nurturers from the mother holding her daughter's hand to the chicken with its hens in the foreground and even the little girl feeding those chickens alluding to learning her future role. While the feelings and roles of the females are put on display on left of the painting, cultural tendencies of the males are displayed through the exchange of money, recording of the exchange and the curious look of the little boy who almost looks like he is examining the public notary's notes.


Although the Village Bride which appears to be a social commentary, feels far removed from the pastel, fluffy, sensuous painting style of the rococo period, it still retains rococo elements that can be noted in the treatment of the clothing of the females while at the same time introducing geometric elements on the male side attesting to Greuze's role as a link between rococo and Neoclassicism. 

Wednesday, October 5, 2011

End of Rococo and the Call of a New Art

Francois Boucher, The Toilette of Venus, 1751
(Metropolitan Museum of Art)
The respect and power Louis XIV established over all of Europe during the grand siecle had completely vanished during Louis XV's(1715-1774) long reign due to his excesses, extravagance and incompetence in war. The feckless life in Versailles, became even more frivolous, scandalous and detached from the real world.  Madame de Pompadour's protege, Francois Boucher painted pastoral scenes of aristocrats imitating shepherds and farmers frolicking in nature dressed in satins and silks, accompanied by pristine clean dogs and sheep, causing critics to complain "His lovers are shepherds, but incapable of watching a flock." Life in Paris imitated life at court. 1The aristocracy lived only for its pleasure without any idea of the realities of the lower classes.  


Francois Bocher, Dark-Haired Odalisque, 1745
(Musee du Louvre)
Rococo was the style for the decorative and fine arts during Louis XV's reign. The oval frame, pastel pinks, yellows and blues, undulating forms, wooded landscapes, plump bodies and themes of love and seduction were all typical features to be found in rococo paintings.  Even with indoor scenes where there were straight walls in the background, continuous arabesques were more prominent.  While most of the French population suffered, the aristocracy played in a world of make believe behind closed doors. 


Art criticism, came into its own as we understand it today with La Font de Saint-Yenne's pamphlet published in 1747, about the current state of painting in France. In his lengthy pamphlet, La Font severely criticized the decadence of contemporary art, calling out to artists to let go of the frivolous and sensuous subject matter for a return to the grand manner of history painting.2

Jean-Baptist Greuze, Father Reading the Bible to His Children, 1755 
When the philosopher, writer, art critic Diderot reviewed the Salon some twenty years later, he found fault with painting on moral, social and aesthetic grounds, especially calling Boucher depraved.3  He found Boucher blatantly artificial and mercenary, criticizing his formulaic pastorals, parsley trees and powdered female bottoms. 4
Diderot called for a new art that would promote virtue and not vice.

Jean-Baptiste Greuze's genre paintings about drame bourgeois, depicting the lives of the middle classes in an austere way, with elevated virtue could be identified as the perfect models for this new art.  In the etching of Father Reading the Bible to His Children, we see a middle class family who is engrossed in what their father is reading with their backs to the door.  This is a family who is not interested in what is going on outside with the nobility.  The sons are engrossed in what their father is reading, one stands with a solemn expression on his face. Just the fact that the father is reading shows that they are educated. The maid in the background informs us of the financial stability of the family.  It is a clean, orderly, humble setting in an enclosed space, quite a contradiction to Boucher's paintings of nubile ladies carouseing in nature.  With his somber, moralizing paintings Greuze would be the bridge between Rococo and Neoclassicism.


Francois Boucher, Shepherd and Shepherdess Resting, 1761
(Wallace Collection, London)




 Jean-Baptiste Greuze, The Village Bride, 1761
(Musee du Louvre)










































1 Alistair Horne, Seven Ages of Paris, Vintage Books, New York, 149
2  Rémy G. Saisselin, The Enlightenment against the Baroque - Economics and Aesthetics in the Eighteenth Century, University of California Press, 1992; 49
3  Ibid., 50
4  Diderot, Denis translated by John Goodman, Diderot on Art I The Salon of 1765 and Notes on Painting, Yale University 1995, xxiii 
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...